4 ms·
I think the "paradox" comes from how people implicitly assume "any number of sons" is somehow distributed or weighted in a way that favors towards numbers of 1
by Terr_ 8y ago
I think the "paradox" comes from how people implicitly assume "any number of sons" is somehow distributed or weighted in a way that favors towards numbers of 1 or above.
In contrast, "0 sons" is going to describe a full half of all marriages.
- jon_richards 8y agoSame situation with the bus.
- pwagland 8y agoNot really. In the son/daughter case, the calculations are: expected daughters: 1 expected sons: 1/20 + 1/41 + 1/82 + 1/163 + 1/324 + … So number of expected daughters = 1, number of expected sons = 1. In practice since women can't have an infinite number of children, then this wouldn't be an infinite series, so the real number of expected boys would be lower than one, but there you go… Now, for the bus case, you get +1 if your bus turns up first, and -1 for every other bus that turns up first. Assume that it is completely random, then: expected + score is: 1/2 1 expected - score is: 1/2 * -1 + 1/4 * -2 + … Expected + is 0.5, expected - is -1.