3 ms·
I feel almost too defeated to share this. I'm somewhat ignorant on the issue, which might come across as having a politicial leaning. I don't. This is a proxy
by Waterluvian 8y ago
I feel almost too defeated to share this. I'm somewhat ignorant on the issue, which might come across as having a politicial leaning. I don't.
This is a proxy battle for "Big Tech is Liberal and Liberals are trying to shut down Conservative speech", is it? Or am I wrong? If it is, why don't Conservatives just create their own tech stuff? Like what is fundamentally stopping people from being heard if the government isn't the one stopping them? Is it currently too hard to create another registrar so we're stuck with the ones we have?
- fooey 8y agoThis isn't a battle between liberals and conservatives, this is big corporations being terrified of liability. Gab and their ilk are giant targets for lawsuits for negligence and who knows whatever else, and no one wants to the deeper pockets further up the food chain The risk/reward of associating with products like Gab has gotten very negative
- olliej 8y agoThe underlying problem is that the “conservative movement” has decided that when a site decides to ban nazis (and their racist, homophobe, etc friends) that is the same thing as banning “conservatives”.
- fzeroracer 8y agoI have trouble understanding how anyone can defend Gab considering the major meltdown their twitter account is going through, including reaching out to Alex Jones as well as perpetuating alt-right memes and conspiracy theories. No one wants to be associated with Gab because it's clear to anyone that it's a garbage fire of a website. It's similar to what happened with Stormfront.
- paulddraper 8y ago> If it is, why don't Conservative just create their own tech stuff? That's literally what Gab is. > Is it currently too hard to create another registrar so we're stuck with the ones we have? Sort of. In theory it's possible [1], but it's hard enough almost no one does it. Not even Twitter has their own registrar (which it why they went down during the DynDNS attack). [1] https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/accreditation-2012-02-25-en https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/accreditation-2012-02-...
- anarazel 8y ago> > If it is, why don't Conservative just create their own tech stuff? > That's literally what Gab is. You're doing "conservatives" a disservice if you claim that anything with a conservative bent would have to end up as the racist cesspool Gab is, and where Gab constantly makes crazy statements themselves (FFS, https://twitter.com/Popehat/status/1056266704148262912 https://twitter.com/Popehat/status/1056266704148262912 )
- Waterluvian 8y agoInteresting. So right or wrong, hate or not, illegal or not, there's ultimately a corporation somewhere deciding if you get a domain name to point at your content. I guess there's also an ISP and all of that also involved. I wonder how much this changes or should change if the Internet was to be considered a fundamental right. Mentally rambling now. Anyway, thanks for the link.
- soneil 8y agoIt's turtles all the way down. You can host your own services, but better hope your colo doesn't decide you're more trouble than you're worth. Build out your own datacenter, but hope your ISP(s) don't decide you're more trouble than you're worth. Build out your own ISP, but hope anyone wants to peer with you. And that's just on the transit side. We've a growing history of piracy sites having their access to the DNS infrastructure curtailed, and porn sites finding the only payment processors who'll touch them charge above and beyond for the 'privilege'. It becomes difficult to ignore that members of society do depend on the rest of society.
- iamnothere 8y agoWait until the banking and credit systems step into the censorship game. (The banks already shut out porn sites, adult performers, and legal cannabis businesses.) Payment processors are just the tip of the iceberg. Imagine not being able to take out your rent money because the banks have "deplatformed" you! That's where we're headed. It's going to turn really nasty when the political enemy du jour shifts away from Literal Nazis and back to anti-government critics, environmentalists, and the like.