3 ms·
A similar HN submission came up a few days ago about how MOOCs can be a replacement for a PhD: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18293418 https://news.ycombi
by minimaxir 8y ago
A similar HN submission came up a few days ago about how MOOCs can be a replacement for a PhD: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18293418 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18293418
Data-oriented MOOCs like Andrew Ng’s Coursera course on Machine Learning and fast.ai’s course on Deep Learning are good academic introductions to the theory and terminology behind data science and other related fields. Although MOOCs have many practice problems to solve, they don’t make you an expert in the field capable of handling messier real-world problems, nor claim to do so. (my longer blog post on the subject: https://minimaxir.com/2018/10/data-science-protips/ https://minimaxir.com/2018/10/data-science-protips/)
More importantly, actually getting the job nowadays is near impossible without a Masters/PhD due to the competition. (the statistical trick with MOOC/boot camp job placement is that the candidate often has a Masters/PhD in a different field, not necessarily in AI)
- jefft255 8y agoI don't think MOOCs can come even close to be a replacement for a PhD (and from what I understand, neither do you). If a candidate who learned with MOOCs can apply for a job which previously "required" a PhD, then that requirement was simply misguided in the first place. A PhD in (AI, CS, stats or whatever else) does not teach you how to be a good all-around data-scientist, it teaches you how to conduct scientific research. In AI this means either developing or improving algorithms, theory work or applying AI to one particular problem for four years. That kind of expertise is not needed for most DS jobs and never was. In my opinion however it is a good rule of thumb to assume that someone with a PhD in a relevant field will become a good data scientist after an adjustment period.
- minimaxir 8y ago> If a candidate who learned with MOOCs can apply for a job which previously "required" a PhD, then that requirement was simply misguided in the first place. Therein lies the problem. A lot of people I've talked with in leadership positions but without a statistical background believe that data science/AI requires a PhD, and since there's a healthy supply of candidates with the PhDs, there isn't much reason to reevaluate that position. (that's more for traditional job positions; obviously research positions will benefit more from a PhD.)
- janoc 8y agoThe problem is that when you put people without formal training in charge of building and training models, you get also results that match - models with horrible biases, models that don't reflect the reality at all, models that are worse than taking random guesses. Running through a bunch of tutorials and then taking a deep learning toolkit (e.g. Tensorflow or Keras) and starting to feed data into it won't teach you squat about the importance of having a representative sample, about removing biases from the data, about correctly handling outliers, about doing some basic statistical analysis on the data to see whether they are even relevant to the problem at hand and so on and so forth. Or even how to build a questionnaire/experiment so that you don't get only a load of expensive garbage instead of data out of it. This is what a doctorate and the associated research training generally give you. Of course, it is not anything that couldn't be learned without doing a formal PhD, publishing research papers and defending a thesis but it is typically the background you won't get from these MOOCs or various online (and offline) "data science" trainings.
- sizzle 8y agoGreat answer. What if you learned basic stats, calculus etc during a masters or BSci degree?
- gaius 8y agoMy take on this is what's needed to succeed in DS/ML in a commercial setting is a) domain knowledge b) the diligence to acquire, clean, and generally pre-process the data and c) some fairly basic knowledge of ML. Someone with amazing ML skills but no knowledge of the problem domain will fail. Someone without domain knowledge will be unable to assemble and curate the data they need and will be unable to make any sense of the output. That is the Achilles heel of ML rockstars who think it's just a matter of getting enough data into their training set and the NN will do the rest.