6 ms·
Scooters and electric bicycles are the sensible form of electric mobility, but everybody talks about electric cars. Which makes sense, since billion dollar comp
by adrianN 8y ago
Scooters and electric bicycles are the sensible form of electric mobility, but everybody talks about electric cars. Which makes sense, since billion dollar companies can make a lot more money selling cars than cheap scooters and bicycles.
Small electric vehicles effectively solve the last mile problem of public transport.
- KozmoNau7 8y agoElectric cars are more impressive to the average person, especially the quiet smooth acceleration compared to ICE cars. And of course they have AC and comfy seats and all that, which appeals to people's comfortable laziness. But the real transport revolution is a combination of public transit and bikes/scooters for the so-called last mile.
- clarry 8y ago> Scooters and electric bicycles are the sensible form of electric mobility, but everybody talks about electric cars. Yes, because cars make sense when you've got more than your own arse to haul. Or when you don't want to end up in your destination dripping wet. Or when you want to sit in a warm cabin instead of fighting frostburns on a bicycle. Or when you don't want to be slipping on ice or getting stuck in snow..
- gregknicholson 8y agoYou could get most of those things using an electric cargo bike with a canopy roof/windscreen. It wouldn't solve the Fred Flintstone problem — The Man must provide the propulsion for all of his family because Man — but that's a social hurdle, not a technical one.
- clarry 8y agoI don't think it's roof or windscreen, it's both if you want to stay dry. That's a big increase in size, mass, and wind resistance (including susceptibility to side winds that can tip you over). That might have you consider having more than two wheels for stability, and windshield wipers, and a big battery to haul all that... at some point, we'll be wondering whether it's a car with pedals or a bike? https://www.daimler.com/company/tradition/company-history/1885-1886.html https://www.daimler.com/company/tradition/company-history/18...
- adrianN 8y agoYou can build electric cars that are traditional two ton vehicles or you could build electric "cars" that weigh 95% less but still protect you from the elements. Like the PodRide https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F4xgpOBrEp4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F4xgpOBrEp4
- JabavuAdams 8y agoYou must live somewhere warm. I'm getting sad just thinking of my winter commute. Winter is coming. Bleargh. Wait, there's magic bubble of warmth and comfort that will take me to my destination without having to mill around with the other cold yet sweaty 99% Chimpanzees in their puffy insulated layers? Sold!
- gregknicholson 8y ago> You must live somewhere warm. Not especially :) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manchester#Climate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manchester#Climate > Wait, there's magic bubble of warmth and comfort that will take me to my destination without having to mill around with the other cold yet sweaty 99% Chimpanzees in their puffy insulated layers? Sold! A lot of people don't actually seem to be sold on this, though. They seem aggrieved when it isn't also faster than walking, cycling and public transport, because they've been sold a top speed. In the local news this week: https://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/greater-manchester-news/night-manchester-ground-halt-15324465 https://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/greater-manches... But a car takes up several times more area on the ground, compared to the same number of people walking or using wheelchairs, bicycles or buses — there just isn't room for every individual to have that level of luxury and leave room to move at speed. I found this essay insightful: http://unevenearth.org/2018/08/the-social-ideology-of-the-motorcar/ http://unevenearth.org/2018/08/the-social-ideology-of-the-mo... — via https://www.notechmagazine.com/2018/08/no-tech-reader-19.html https://www.notechmagazine.com/2018/08/no-tech-reader-19.htm...
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoLike this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=037CAW4Yeug https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=037CAW4Yeug
- stephengillie 8y agoIt's like GP has never shopped at Costco. Edit: or had elderly parents. When someone needs to use a walker, good luck getting them on a bicycle. Plus, where do you carry the walker?
- adrianN 8y agoI have an elderly mother. She uses a cargo tricycle. She can't drive.
- village-idiot 8y ago“Some people can’t use bikes, therefore they’re dumb” is a bad argument.
- TomMarius 8y agoWell, the actual argument is "Some people can’t use bikes, therefore banning cars is dumb". EDIT: I made a factual statement. If you downvote me for it, at least have the courtesy to say why. If there's something dumb, it's downvoting for factual statements that aren't even expressing either opinion.
- village-idiot 8y agoYou’re probably getting downvoted for making up what people are talking about and then arguing against it, which is a straw man. Advocating for more people to use car-less transit more often is not the same as banning cars.
- TomMarius 8y agoHuh, what? Saying that anyone says "bikes are dumb" isn't making up what people are talking about? The argument revolves around the fact that there are a lot of situations when a car(-like vehicle) is appropriate, not that bikes are dumb as a whole. Literally no one says bikes are dumb.
- 8y ago
- lorenzhs 8y agoAll of these points are brought up a lot, but none of them are really valid. Cargo bikes (with electric assist, if you wish) can haul a tremendous amount of cargo or multiple kids. And weather is really only a problem if you're badly equipped. Get a hardshell jacket and some rainpants, and rain is no longer a problem. Get a warm jacket, gloves, and a hat against the cold (maybe some warm leggings if it gets really cold). And people not knowing how to behave on icy roads is a major problem if that person is steering a car. On a properly equipped bike, not so much.
- clarry 8y ago> All of these points are brought up a lot, but none of them are really valid. Dude, I've been cycling in all weather for 20 years. I've been hauling stuff, small and big, light and heavy. It's not as simple as you make it out to be. I've gotten stuck in snow so many times. Turns out a bicycle just doesn't have a whole lot of traction or stability when riding a crumbling layer of snow on ice. No, studs don't fix it, and cargo definitely doesn't help it. At least I can hop off and hike the bike, but maybe not if it's a heavy electric cargo bike with guitars and work equipment loaded. I've gotten soaked so many times, and even if I've got an outer layer that keeps me dry, there are many destinations you might want to go to where they don't exactly have the facilities for you to strip and put away dripping rain gear. I've also got my cargo soaked so many times, turns out protecting the cargo from water isn't quite as easy as putting a nice jacket on. I can only imagine how much harder it gets when you're trying to haul big cargo. And I've gotten soaked many times because weather can be unpredictable and having full rain gear on you where ever you go is a little too nuts. And no matter how much I dress, getting glasses completely dirtied with water mist or the face blasted with wind when it's -35degC outside isn't any fun, at all. I'd say I'm a rather avid cyclist, hell I rode my fixed gear road bike with 25mm road wheels to work, on snow and ice, on the coldest of winter days, because the grease on my winter bike's freewheel stiffened up and prevented the pawls from engaging. I go pretty far. But I would not expect the general population to want or even be able to put up with anywhere near as much. And then you need to make a trip longer than you can handle on a bike.
- lorenzhs 8y ago
- village-idiot 8y agoThere is no such thing as bad weather, only bad clothing.
- stephengillie 8y agoThere's a reason motorcycles are common in the summer in WA State, but very rare in the winter. You'll arrive completely drenched if you're not in a car. Not only is there rain, sometimes sideways rain, but also lots of roadway spray. At times, there are "greyout" conditions where you can't see more than 100 feet down the freeway, for all the water in the air. Seattle's former Mayor Mike McGinn used a bicycle to commute, and often arrived at city meetings as a sweaty and smelly person. Most businesses don't have a shower for bicyclists.
- mikestew 8y agoI’ll agree that motorcycle use drops off dramatically during the winter in WA. I did a gig at a large coffee comapny’s corporate HQ, and in the summer motorcycle parking was packed and finding a space could be difficult. In winter, there were days I’d be the only bike. But one does not have to get soaked. It’ll take $1000 worth of gear, but I arrive bone-dry every day. Aerostich Darien, good boots, decent gloves. Finding a place to hang the dripping gear when you get there can be a problem. In the end, gear or not, as what some consider to be a “hard-core” rider I will say it’s still easier to toss the bag in the car and turn the key on a rainy day. Which wraps us around to what I take to be your point: for all-round use and convenience in all conditions, it’s hard to beat a car. Unless one lives close to work in southern California, there are plenty of scenarios where one better be “dedicated to the cause” to use alternate transportation year-round.
- icebraining 8y agoMost businesses don't have a shower for bicyclists. Which is exactly the point. Why do business have endless space (theirs or public) for people to park their cars, yet don't have the minimal infrastructure for two wheel commuters? Because the conversation surrounding mobility is still mostly about cars.
- liftbigweights 8y ago> but everybody talks about electric cars. Everyone talks about it because that's where the market is. If you think scooters and electric bicycles are the future, you should liquidate all your assets and start up a scooter/electric bicycle business and if your instincts are right, then you are a billionaire. You might want to look into what customers want first though. Survey after survey ( in both cities, suburbs and rural areas ) show that americans want big cars - even for the last mile. And good luck trying to get new yorkers to embrace scooters or electric bicycles when half the year is either extremely humid and hot or dry and freezing.
- village-idiot 8y agoI see an order of magnitude more electric bikes and scooters per day than I see EVs. Turns out price matters.
- briandear 8y agoNot in Silicon Valley where nearly every other car is an EV and riding bikes around here is close to suicide. On my commute from Mountain View to Cupertino, I see hundreds of Tesla’s and I am often the only electric scooter on the road.
- village-idiot 8y agoYou’re in an unusually rich area. Down here in LA, which I believe is slightly less rich than SV, I still see more scooters than Teslas, and this is a car friendly area.
- loceng 8y agoI honestly wouldn't feel safe on an electric scooter, especially as scooter traffic increases. Likewise, there's a stat/research that was recently shared in another thread on HN referencing increase in accidents/collisions relating to a decrease in gas costs, meaning poorer people - who drive less and other factors would impact them too - get onto the road again, and this same demographic who can't normally afford to drive would then be able to afford scooters. Yes, this is good for accessibility - assuming they are fit to drive or "scoot."
- adrianN 8y agoWell, I don't feel safe with lots of cars around me, I'd rather have fewer cars and more scooters.
- loceng 8y agoAs a pedestrian or as a driver of a vehicle? And if a pedestrian, it's clear people are complaining that there are people are riding on sidewalks - when perhaps they shouldn't - so that seems less safe. And that's a pretty general statement. Could you explain why you feel safe unsafe with cars around you?
- smileysteve 8y ago> Could you explain why you feel safe unsafe with cars around you? A 150lb person on a scooter or bike runs into somebody at 15mph; the most likely outcome is everybody walks away, with small chances of death, and mediocre chances of broken bones. A 3500lb car doesn't see a scooter, bicyclist, pedestrian and turns into them; and your best outcome approaches serious injury and your expected outcome becomes death. woefully overinvested streets and underinvested sidewalks; And woefully under trained drivers.
- loceng 8y agoAs possible counters: vehicles are larger, and pedestrians are more likely to see and/or hear them; this changes with electric vehicles becoming more silent, however should be counter-balanced and improved with AI and autonomous driving protecting pedestrians. I'm quite certain scooters go faster than 15mph as well? I could be wrong though. You also don't expect vehicles to drive on the sidewalk, however as I said, scooters on the sidewalk seems to be a problem; equally what can be dangerous are motorized wheelchairs who I've experienced a few times going full speed, driving recklessly.
- Spooky23 8y agoIt solves everything for 18-35 year olds without kids in a city in California, as long as you do not get into or cause an accident. When you get hurt or hurt someone through your actions, you’ll have the problem is of dealing with injury or liability without insurance. If you live in a place that is not California and has wind, rain, snow, etc, you have a solution that works some days. I bike about 8-10 miles to work, but end up doing it about 40% of the time, because life.
- stale2002 8y agoSolving Intercity commuting is a huge category that would revolutionize transportation. With this large category of people off the road, therr would be lots more space for everyone else, which would help in terms of traffic, ect
- azemetre 8y agoI work in Cambridge, MA and I see families with children and babies on bikes all the time. I see them bike in the rain, snow, and heat. Of course when there's a bad storm you won't see many (if any bike) but neither would you see vehicles driving about either). I don't really see this as an ageist argument. More of people don't want to give up their comforts because they aren't paying the true external costs.
- adrianN 8y agoIf we'd get everyone to cut their car use by 60% that would already be huge.
- d-- 8y agoI really support this and am an avid cyclist myself. But this really only works in temperate (and dry) climates. If it rains, we'll have a hard time to convince people to use something without a build-in roof.
- ip26 8y agoPeople like comfort, and don't like to change their behavior. That is why. Same reason why nobody was interested in the original Insight (2 door, dorky, 70mpg), but the Prius (just like a regular hatch, 50mpg) sold like hotcakes