4 ms·
So how do you organize legal cases with over 66,000 pages of paperwork? I know that blowing cases up to this size is standard operating procedure, but I'm curi
by btilly 16y ago
So how do you organize legal cases with over 66,000 pages of paperwork? I know that blowing cases up to this size is standard operating procedure, but I'm curious how it is handled in practice.
- johngalt 16y agoUsually you setup an organization and review routine, where lower level attorneys do the initial pass and escalate important documents. Let me tell you that 66,000 is nothing. Civil litigation can easily surpass 200k-300k documents. There are a lot of tools out there to help with this (concordance, IPro, Summation).
- smalter 16y agoas a former lawyer who has handled large and small document reviews, i can say that both doc review platforms i used, concordance and caselogistix are horrendous and there is certainly an opportunity here for someone to do this right.
- btilly 16y agoUnfortunately this classifies as enterprise software, and therefore the quality of the software is not particularly important for its adoption. See http://lists.canonical.org/pipermail/kragen-tol/2005-April/000772.html http://lists.canonical.org/pipermail/kragen-tol/2005-April/0... for more on this.
- ssp 16y agoA bit of a tangent, but would something like source control (git, hg) be useful to lawyers? If they are cutting and pasting from older documents all the time, it seems like it would.
- smalter 16y agoi think within most big law firms, there may be an enormous team which reviews documents, but when it comes to drafting documents, even at the biggest firms those teams are relatively small. i helped draft a section of a 2000 page document and the whole document just consisted of separate word documents with subjects like "chapter 1 rev2 final 9-3-2009.doc" which are passed around via email. but since the teams are relatively small, there aren't that many versions floating around so that can do a passable, if sometimes irritating, job. there are some types of version control already out there which lawyers use, e.g., hummingbird dm. it's pretty lame and annoying to use which is why many lawyers i know just do what i describe above for version control. so bottom line: yes, it'd be useful, but it would have to be very easy to use otherwise people would just use marginally more annoying but in some ways much easier to use (don't have to learn how to do something new) methods.
- btilly 16y agoMy immediate thought as a non-lawyer is that source control works better with plain text than it does with binary data in proprietary formats. Unfortunately lawyers have to deal with a lot of real world data from random IT systems, much of which will come as images, Word documents, spreadsheets, etc. So the idea of source control is probably useful. The current state of the art? Maybe less so.
- seanalltogether 16y agolegal software is such a lucrative market for someone to do something right. lawyers are so ass backwards in terms of technology, and the problem is it's not a profession where tech entrepreneurs normally grow out of. One of my good friends works at an office where the secretaries put everyones tasks in to outlook just so they can have the calendar pop up telling them which case to work on from one hour to the next. Developer task management tools are light years ahead of the law world.
- flipbrad 16y agoit's not just task management: as a newbie to the legal world, I would like to learn about software development / good coding practice to improve my contract drafting (which, not being a coder, I think of in the following terms: define the variables; find the right includes; structure it appropriately, in modules if possible; test; annotate)
- elblanco 16y agoI think there are a couple barriers to entry for new people to watch out for (having tried to go down this path in a past venture): 1) Don't try and save time (or at least don't focus on that), lawyers charge by time spent, saving time looses them money. 2) Your product needs good OCR. Many times, documents, even electronic ones, are printed out on paper, delivered in boxes, then scanned back in...don't ask why, that's just the way the world works. 3) You'll need pretty robust searching, tagging and entity extraction and case management in your product. 4) Visualization doesn't hurt. 5) There's many kinds of law, pick one (patent law) and focus on it. While there's some crossover between different sub-disciplines, they're different enough that you kinda have to just support one to start with. 6) You'll want a very robust data index and retrieval system that can handle millions of documents at scale. "Lots of documents" is not in the 4 digit thousands, they have paralegals and newbie lawyers to go through that amount of stuff, "Lots of documents" is 20,000->2 or 3 million documents. It's at the larger number that you'll be providing real value. No matter how much time the firm wants to charge for this kind of research work, they can't charge infinity, so their coverage of the material will always just be some subset. 7) Learn about the kinds of pricing models that'll work for you clients. Surprisingly, most law firms don't want to buy software, they want to lease it for the length of the case. 8) Most lawyers have the computer skills of a 90 year old man. It can't be a super technical system.
- andrew1 16y ago> 1) Don't try and save time (or at least don't focus on that), lawyers charge by time spent, saving time looses them money. But if you became quick enough that you could make a point of it to your clients, then presumably you could charge more per hour. Exaggerated example, but if you could say to your clients (and back it up with previous cases) that the work that other companies are quoting them a year to do will only take you six months, but you want 50% more per hour then that works out well for the both of you?
- elblanco 16y agoYou'd probably need some really good and hard metrics on that to make a case...say my lawyer normally charges $400/hr, now she wants to charge me $700/hr but claims, "I can do it twice as fast". I'm not sure I'm totally sold on that claim. I found that the time saving messaging fell absolutely flat (we can cover the same number of documents x-times faster). The only message that resonated was the coverage messaging (we can cover more documents during the limited discovery period)...and then only with firms that were working cases that involved hundreds of thousands of documents -- too much for them to staff up on. The case/document management aspect of it seems to be where the real interest level lies and if you can offer lots of capability for drawing connections between disparate groups of documents it could have some true value. A digital organizer capable of aiding connection building. At least that's what I remember. We did a bit of research into the market before deciding not to chase it due to the level of funding we would need to get a product to market.
- thevectorist 16y agoRelativity is a more modern alternative to Concordance. http://www.kcura.com http://www.kcura.com
- anigbrowl 16y agoThis is tiny, I'm sorry to say! E-discovery requests now yield millions of documents as a matter of routine. Mrs Browl works for a company in this sector, though I'd rather not say which one (it isn't mentioned in this thread though, and yes, most software in this area is hideous). This is the industry reference that everyone more or less agrees on: http://edrm.net/ http://edrm.net/ Essentially one side can request any and all data concerning people/places/events in the case, though they have to specify (loosely) what they want and why, and what format they want it delivered in - some want native files, some PDFs, some TIFF images, some even want paper. Typically attorneys of both the plaintiff and defendant work through the terms of a court order, then the defendant's lawyers do a big data collection with the aid of forensic specialists, possibly supervised by the plaintiff's attorneys. This can be as disruptive as an IRS audit, but across the entire company - engineering, sales, business development, finance, executive suite, you name it. Assume everything will be collected, and I do mean everything: the idea is to get a snapshot of all relevant data that was available on the date the court granted the motion. Many firms are now moving towards just archiving everything ahead of time to avoid disrupting operations. Also, that makes it much easier to manage as a rolling process for both sides later. As well as the original files, there's a giant database of all textual content (including transcriptions of audio/video) and case-specific legal metadata referencing the source material. The plaintiff isn't entitled to see all of this stuff, but is entitled to know it has been preserved as evidence whose completeness can be verified legally, so everything's numbdered and tracked from here on. Then the defendant's lawyers go through looking for a) anything that could fall within the scope of the court order, b) what they think the Plaintiff is going to use against them in particular, and c) what the defendant is entitled to keep from them (eg the communications between the CEO and company counsel, or material which is just not relevant to the plaintiff's case). They build (a) by doing wide-ranging database searches for each legal issue in the case, of which there can be many. Then a team of review attorneys looks at every document individually to see if it's responsive (relevant) to the issue and/or privileged (legally private), maybe adding a short description that will go into a list of evidence. In a big case like Google v. Oracle there can be over 100 attorneys doing this for months on end, factory style. They're usually contractors, not employees. 5 years ago this paid $60-75/hour or more; now it typically pays half that, and some companies pay as little as $15/hour. The job is so basic that only minimal qualifications are required, so now a lot of material is sent to India; because a bunch of law schools got certified in the years before the financial crisis and many more exaggerated hiring stats for their grads, there's a huge surplus of JDs and far fewer jobs; a lot of law firms went bust in the crisis, and a lot more complain schools graduate too many theorists unprepared to actually practice law; and most of these grads are $1-200k in non-dischargeable debt for their student loans. Hence debt-ridden attorneys being offered $15/hour. Naturally they aren't happy, and everyone is waiting to see if (more like when) a class action lawsuit gets filed against the whole legal education establishment. In the meantime, most law schools still charge at least $30k/year in tuition. After the review team has classified everything to legal standards, the defendant's attorneys - the ones earning real money this time - then go through double and triple checking what's responsive, redact any information that might be privileged, and approving each document required for production to the plaintiff, they're all given another set of numbers and converted to the agreed-upon output format. They also (typically) approve lots more documents which look responsive but aren't and are safe to give away, so as to bury the plaintiff's attorneys in as much irrelevant data as they possibly can - because the plaintiff's lawyers don't get access to this trove of metadata, just the bare document in digital or occasionally printed form. Then the other side puts all those into a big database of their own, hires a smaller bunch of review attorneys, and does essentially the same thing. Often the defendant has launched a countersuit against them in the meantime, and requests discovery of the original plaintiff's documents...this process sometimes takes a few years before the trial proper starts. There are huge profits to be had, but lots of competition; also most law firms are conservative about technology. So it's not a fast buck.