4 ms·
> When I refer to tools for learning statistics, I mean things like applets, TinkerPlots, and Fathom....You can't put TinkerPlots on your resume, and if you act
by gumby 8y ago
> When I refer to tools for learning statistics, I mean things like applets, TinkerPlots, and Fathom....You can't put TinkerPlots on your resume, and if you actually want to apply the skills you've learned to real data, you need to learn another tool.
I can't really see why this is a problem as stated. You probably used a textbook as well, and you can't put that textbook on your resume either. Just because it's software doesn't make it different.
> So, the first thing that a future tool for statistical programming should do is bridge the gap between learning and doing. I think that a good tool should be able to ease people into programming, using some sort of visual, drag-and-drop interface that exposes novices to the entire trajectory of data analysis (data import, cleaning, new variable creation, plots, summary statistics, models). Then, it should have a way to make the transition to more traditional or textual coding. Ideally, one could look back and forth between the visual representation and the textual one, and a change in one interface would be reflected as a change in the other.
In statics, as programming, it's not clear a drag-and-drop pedagogical interface helps much (believe me, I"ve worked with such systems since I was a kid in the late 70s). This paragraph quoted above, and the part of the article above it, actually have the solution: use a bunch of helper code in R (which is what they use now) but generate the realtime results in an adjacent window. This is the approach used by LOGO back in, yes, the 1970s: you'd type a program (in a real programming language -- basically a Lisp) and see the results immediately. You could go back and modify the program and see those results immediately.
- xte 8y agoToday's "notebook UI" seems to be popular (think about Jupyter, Mathematica, SaGe, ...) and in the end they are graphic-sugar and a bit limited org-mode implementation... On "graphic programming" LOGO was a toy, SmallTalk (actually Squeak) are another story (and the basis of very first modern workstation, the Xerox Alto) :-)
- infinite8s 8y agoLOGO was not a toy, it was a means to teach children the basics of differential geometry.
- xte 8y agoOk, but try to use it for anything else today...
- infinite8s 8y agoDo you expect to hammer a nail with a screwdriver?