14 ms·
The reason Smalltalk didn’t take over the world was it was so resource intensive. A single workstation would have cost about $40,000. There’s no way the early M
by simonh 8y ago
The reason Smalltalk didn’t take over the world was it was so resource intensive. A single workstation would have cost about $40,000. There’s no way the early Macs could have run Smalltalk, they only became capable of that years later and it was slow as molasses. I suppose it should really have had a chance by the Java era, but C style syntax languages ruled the world and the state of the art had moved on by then.
- rjsw 8y agoA Mac Plus could run Smalltalk.
- lispm 8y agoApple ran Smalltalk 80 on the Lisa, Mac Plus, Mac II and a small version on the Mac 512k. A Mac II or IIfx would probably be faster than a Xerox system - which generally were not very powerful.
- pinewurst 8y agoParcPlace Systems was shipping fast, production-grade Smalltalk-80 on the Mac II with JIT compilation (PS and HPS VMs) in 1988. It was certainly faster than cruddy D-machines (other than Dorado of course) and their final Xerox successors.
- ksec 8y agoBut would it take over the world today? Our latest smartphone properly have 10x to 100x the processor power of the "$40,000" Workstation back then. I am not entirely sure if Smalltalk was the right approach, most people, the 98% who don't read HN don't want to code. I think Hypercard is a much closer to that vision but it doesn't seems there are massive interest for something like that either, The world today is like 90% consumption, people consume news, media, video etc.
- protomyth 8y agoGiven thing today where a hero jpeg is bigger than most Smalltalk’s VM images, it would be fine. The problem is we are in a Unix / Windows world and getting popular now is a lot harder.
- scroot 8y ago> it doesn't seems there are massive interest for something like that either It's been a long enough time that most people don't even know that "Hypercard like things" are even possible, or what they mean, or how one could use them. The "appification" of personal computing has ensured that there are "programmers" and "users" (scribes and plebs) and that the relationship will be transactional and commercial. > he world today is like 90% consumption, people consume news, media, video etc. The more the development community realizes this, the better off we will be -- because it will become clear that in a technical sense a completely different way (ie the direction of Smalltalk or Hypercard) is possible and that the truly limiting factors are cultural more than anything else.
- igouy 8y agoJuly 11, 1988 — "Digitalk to Ship Mac Version of Smalltalk: … will run on Mac Plus, Mac SE, or Mac II and will require 1 megabyte of memory." https://books.google.com/books?id=5T4EAAAAMBAJ&pg=PA3 https://books.google.com/books?id=5T4EAAAAMBAJ&pg=PA3 > I suppose it should really have had a chance by the Java era … pdf "Ubiquitous Applications: Embedded Systems to Mainframes" http://www.davethomas.net/papers/ubiquitous1995.pdf http://www.davethomas.net/papers/ubiquitous1995.pdf