6 ms·
After just finishing "Bad Blood", the book by John Carreyrou on the Theranos fraud, this particular passage in the article had me incensed: > This week a lawye
by hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
After just finishing "Bad Blood", the book by John Carreyrou on the Theranos fraud, this particular passage in the article had me incensed:
> This week a lawyer for Advanced Dermatology and Cosmetic Surgery, which is backed by private equity and is the largest dermatology practice in the United States, called the general counsel at the University of Florida, where two of the authors are employed, demanding specific changes to the paper.
I'm disgusted by these high-powered law firms using thuggish tactics to try to silence critics. I have no problem with these lawyers responding to the article, in public, after it is published, but using the threat of expensive litigation to shut people up is just gross and morally bankrupt.
- gaius 8y agoI'm disgusted by these high-powered law firms using thuggish tactics to try to silence critics. The actions of Boies law firm, as documented in the book, are particularly egregious. Worse still is that Boies himself has a track record of being super tech savvy; he’s litigated against Microsoft and Google. As he was a board member at Theranos, it stretches credulity that he wasn’t more aware of the deception. Paid in equity too, how is that not a conflict of interest? How is it even legal?
- fjsolwmv 8y agoHow is a conflict of interest to be paid by your client to represent their interests?
- gaius 8y agoIt hinges on how plausible the scenario is that you can be a board member with a history of effortlessly mastering complex technical concepts, and all around you are whistleblowers asserting that the technology is a fraud, in which case your equity is worthless, and you decide that the best course of action is to abuse the legal system to intimidate them into silence. It's documented in the book that the family of one whistleblower ran up massive debts defending themselves, and a key scientist was hounded into committing suicide. It's not mentioned in the book that any of the lawyers ever wondered if maybe there might be something in all these reports. Anyway, read the book and draw your own conclusions about the characters involved.
- matthewdgreen 8y agoIt creates an environment where the attorney is incentivized to protect his/her own investment in the company, above and beyond representing the company's interest and the interest of the law.
- maxxxxx 8y agoI don't think it's a conflict of interest. They got paid by Theranos for their services. But there should be some ethics about helping clients with a lot of money bullying people with no money. Reading about the way Theranos abused whistleblowers with the help of lawyers was infuriating. The little guy simply has no chance against this unless you are willing to risk everything.
- mrnobody_67 8y agoHe got paid in stock. $4.5m worth if I recall from the book
- hawkice 8y agoThese aren't critics. These are scientists. Changing their results to suit corporate interests is a fire-able offense, and they are honor-bound to not retract unless the truth of their results are in question. Giving overly generous Yelp reviews is fine, who cares? Publishing "generous" science as fact is morally wrong.
- adrian_mrd 8y agoAgree. Related thought: the influence of lawyers in tech firms - witness the draconian EULAs users are 'forced' to accept with a false binary choice of accept or not - and the role that corporate law staff have had in software development, by effectively limiting the rights of users. It seems to me that many technology firms copy-and-paste the soul of EULAs to protect themselves (against the worse cases that may arise) with little thought about the effect these long list of restrictions cause. It often seems it cascaded from Microsoft's use of EULAs from Windows 95, Office 95 and onwards, because it was the norm to consumers in that 'monopoly' environment. The role of lawyers in suppressing ideas, choices and debate - be it in healthcare (the USA dermatology sector as per the OP article) or in technology - the Hacker News set - warrants further debate. Especially if ethics are to play a greater role in the future of technology - as seems to be the general consensus of forward-thinking governments and progressive technologists.
- losteric 8y agoI think this legal arms race is a consequence of America's overly-litigious and profitable legal system. These EULAs are the equivalent of warning labels on soda bottles that loosely read "Warning: Contents under pressure, don't point at your eyes"... who is that written for? We laugh and call it unnecessary, but that warning exists because there is precedent that must now be defended against. When those ludicrous cases are widely used as a means of attack or personal enrichment, of course corporations will respond with excessive legal restrictions. Their shareholders don't want to lose money to frivolous lawsuits or be exposed to risks competitors have covered.
- WalterSear 8y agoA warning is not a contract.
- mcny 8y agoI anal but it might be worth looking into making EULA null and void. But first (sorry for sounding like a broken record), we must repeal the cfaa.
- Hermel 8y agoI think it is ok to contact the authors of a paper if you think they got something wrong or omitted something important. However, here it was not a scientist calling the authors, but a lawyer calling the general counsel. This is a clear hint that the call was not about correcting an error in the paper, but about bullying them and preventing the public from reading what the authors have to say.
- phkahler 8y ago>> I'm disgusted by these high-powered law firms... It's not the lawyers so much as the private equity folks who hired them. Asking lawyers to forego business on [subjective] moral grounds is similar to doing so for engineers - like recent refusals to work on government projects. Some will, some won't.
- xenophonf 8y agoThis is the moral equivalent of "I was just following orders." You always have a choice whether to engage in unethical behavior, and subverting the scientific process certainly qualifies as such.
- Waterluvian 8y agoThis isn't really about the lawyers though. It's about industries getting so large and so centralized that it becomes economical to throw money (aka. lawyers) at quieting a dissenting paper. It might not even be to try to get changes made, it might have its value in researchers thinking about how irritating and time consuming and possibly stressful it is to speak up next time.
- rayiner 8y agoThere is nothing “thuggish” about demanding corrections of factual errors, and it’s not “gross and morally bankrupt” to engage to talk about those changes instead of waiting for the damage to be done after inaccurate facts are published. The law protects you from that. I suspect that you’re presupposing, without a basis, that the cited errors are not errors but rather unflattering characterizations.
- jacquesm 8y agoIn any scientists-vs-lawyers battle I would be more than happy to let the scientists publish before the lawyers get to have their say. It is possible that this is a complaint on merits but given the past performance of the legal profession in situations like these the chances are much better than even that they are protecting some commercial interest rather than that they are suddenly interested in accurate and factual reporting by scientists.
- rayiner 8y agoThe lawyers work for the clients, which in this case are other doctors.
- jacquesm 8y agoThat is not an accurate description of the situation as far as I can see it. The one group of doctors is a bunch of researchers, the other group is a large corporate entity that makes gobs of money from certain products.
- rayiner 8y ago> Dr. Matt Leavitt heads Advanced Dermatology and Cosmetic Surgery, the largest dermatology practice in the United States, which is backed by private equity. It is one of the practices that objected to the article.
- ItsMe000001 8y ago