2 ms·
It is not only about bugs. It is also about the question whether everybody can wrap their head around it. This is a problem with every electronic/digital voting
by atoav 8y ago
It is not only about bugs. It is also about the question whether everybody can wrap their head around it. This is a problem with every electronic/digital voting process – even if you are a engineer figuring out if that machine is safe would be not that straightforward.
If speed is not an issue then the voting mechanism that everybody (even the technically unskilled) can understand is the best.
And beeing slow is not a bug, it is a feature. A feature that prevents all kinds of things from happening that would undermine trust in the system as a whole.
- greglindahl 8y agoWhen I said "errors" I didn't only mean bugs. I mean failing to have a counted vote that's the same as what the voter intended. The method I like most is paper ballots with optical scanners, which the general public can understand. Random audits for confirmation, yes, the general public can understand. Recounts, and hand recounts, yes, the general public can understand.
- jacques_chester 8y agoIt just doesn't take that long to count by hand. You wait an extra day or week or two to get the final count. So what? This has consequences for years, so take your damn time and count every single ballot. A machine cannot be watched in the same way a human can. No scrutineer can prove that a ballot was counted correctly without ... seeing it counted.
- btilly 8y agoAnd beeing slow is not a bug, it is a feature. A feature that prevents all kinds of things from happening that would undermine trust in the system as a whole. 2004, Bush vs Kerry in Ohio. The voting commissioner was Republican and had promised to deliver Ohio. Without Ohio, Bush would not have won the election. Heavily Republican precincts were set up so that voting was easy all day. Heavily Democratic precincts in Cincinnati got so backlogged that they closed the door and people had to be in line for hours to vote. Bush won the state by 2.1%. He carried Harris County, which includes Cincinnati. No Republican has carried Harris County since. Now tell me. Does the feature of voting "beeing slow" improve your faith in the fairness of that election?
- MiddleEndian 8y agoThe voting process should be easy and accessible. Counting the votes does not need to be fast.
- jacques_chester 8y agoVoting machines haven't fixed the problem, which is the lack of independent electoral commissions. And they never will. But paper ballots are far less easy to subvert than machine ballots.