5 ms·
Why is the US so set on voting machine to begin with? They clearly aren't secure, and apparently they are't as user-friendly as the paper ballots they're replac
by mrweasel 8y ago
Why is the US so set on voting machine to begin with? They clearly aren't secure, and apparently they are't as user-friendly as the paper ballots they're replacing?
A few months ago it was announced that Denmark is dropping all plans for electronic voting in the foreseeable future. There a to many issues with the voting machines and holding a paper ballot election is neither expensive nor complicated.
- paulddraper 8y agoEfficency/cost, speed of results, no 2000 hanging chad nonsense. I still think they should be paper, but those are the reasons.
- JorgeGT 8y agoThere's no contradiction between paper ballots and speed. In my country we all vote with paper ballots, then at the closing of the polling stations the members of each voting table punch the results of their urn into a laptop which connects to the electoral authority. In 3-4h max the elections results are out. For security however, after punching the numbers into the laptop, ballots are re-sealed into the urn and physically sent to the electoral authority, where in the following days public officers count them manually again. There has never been any meaningful deviation detected to date. This way, you have the security of paper ballots (they are on sight of party volunteers at all times) with the speed of electronic vote aggregation.
- ASalazarMX 8y agoAre you Mexican? Our system is the same, but a critical factor helps it. Every citizen has a voting credential, and every booth has a list of voters. You can't vote without your id, and while you can vote in secret, you can only vote in your designated booth. This gives the system its agility. Our recent presidential election had a reliable statistical advance (PREP) at 23:00 the same day, and the next day every single vote of every remote booth was fully accounted, and the result confirmed the PREP. The Mexican electoral system is surprisingly effective, yet we have the same core problem of democracy: we need better candidates and less gullible voters :/
- JorgeGT 8y agoClose, Spaniard! But it works here as you describe (even to the last sentence, unfortunately!).
- ASalazarMX 8y agoNot even the Greeks have managed to solve that problem. And they invented democracy!
- jackpirate 8y agoThis thread [1] on /r/Mexico made me think that voting credentials don't work very well. I haven't read any technical analysis of the system, but everyone in the thread is talking about how easy it is to vote multiple times. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/mexico/comments/9rcyyt/ah_caray_no_que_nom%C3%A1s_una_consulta/ https://www.reddit.com/r/mexico/comments/9rcyyt/ah_caray_no_...
- wyldfire 8y agoSome states use paper ballots with bubbles that are filled in with pencil or ink. The benefit is that they're simply tabulated automatically and provide an original record to refer to.
- QuercusMax 8y agoThat's literally the only way I've ever voted, in 2 different states. Scantron is a perfectly reasonably way to do things, and the technology has been around for ages. Voting machines are just plain stupid.
- DaiPlusPlus 8y agoScantron doesn't allow for write-in candidates and it's very easy to design an unusable scantron form that's confusing and difficult to follow. Another issue is that often the scantron circles are small and too close together, making it difficult for people without fine motor control to vote: the solution is a form with much larger circles and spacing but that would be wasteful and inefficient for the majority of voters.
- philwelch 8y agoThe Washington voting system allows for write-in candidates despite also having a bubble that the voter fills in with ink or pencil. If the write-in votes outnumber any of the winning candidates, they could hypothetically count them by hand, but that never really happens.
- Izkata 8y agoIllinois uses a scantron-like system that allows for write-ins: http://ligaya.me/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Illinois-Ballot.jpg http://ligaya.me/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Illinois-Ballot.... You fill in the center of the arrow for who you're voting for, and there's an entry at the bottom for writen-ins. Afterwards this is scanned by a machine and the paper put in storage.
- metildaa 8y agoPaper ballots mailed to voters are speedy, convienent, reliable. Especially when read with a machine. Plus anyone can do Quality Assurace by counting a portion of ballots themselves, and comparing it to the scanned total, making it hard to rig.
- macintux 8y ago> Paper ballots mailed to voters are speedy, convienent, reliable. There are, however, concerns about coercion. Always tradeoffs.
- delecti 8y agoHanging chads are dumb, but just have them be "fill in the box" and not "punch out the hole" ballots and they're not even an issue.
- JshWright 8y agoThere are plenty of issues with 'fill in the bubble' type ballots. Bubbles partially filled in, filled in then crossed out with another bubble filled in, etc...
- Manishearth 8y agoIn Alameda County you deposit non-provisional paper ballots in a scanner which tallies it up. At the end of the day you get a printout of results (assuming there are enough voters to preserve privacy) which is posted outside and submitted to the election office. The machine's flash memory is also submitted, as are the paper ballots. Fast results, but still hand-verifiable.
- dmm 8y agoIt's not all of the US. My state has always used paper.
- sjm-lbm 8y agoTexan here. The funny thing is that, when we go to a polling place on election day, we will almost always get a paper ballot to be used with an optical scan reader. This system actually hits me as an ideal: the electronic reader can be simpler and fairly decoupled from other systems, and each voter will leave a paper trail that should clearly indicate their intent. Admittedly, the electronic readers we use are probabally insecure and awful, but the concept hits me as fairly reasonable. In this case, we are in the early voting period, and there are a reduced number of polling places - and each polling place can be used by any voter in that county, which means that voters might be (and probabally are) voting on slightly different races and using slightly different ballots. These machines remove the need for the early polling places to have a lot of valid paper ballots on hand while still allowing each voter to see and vote in all races they would be able to vote in on election day. It's actually a fairly good use of voting machines, even if it would be nice if the machines were something other than terrible.
- wlll 8y agoThere's a good video on why any computerised or electronic elements in the voting process are a bad idea here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w3_0x6oaDmI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w3_0x6oaDmI
- ghettoimp 8y agoAnother Texan here. That has not been my experience. I've lived and voted in Austin for 15 years and have never seen a single paper ballot. Our voting machines are, and have been, simple screens with a scrolly-wheel interface. They produce no paper record for you to review or deposit anywhere. This would, to me, seem to be a minimum requirement for anyone to have any belief that their vote has been counted correctly.
- warmwaffles 8y agoThere is a paper record. Watch the people running the ballots next time. Your session there was recorded but your vote is not directly tied to you as that would be illegal.
- adrianmonk 8y agoThe 2000 presidential election was really close in the state of Florida. There were some legitimate issues with the design of the paper ballots, and this generated a lot of controversy. This really upset a lot of people and they wanted _something_ to be done. A lot of people naively felt computerizing it would automatically fix everything. They were wrong, but that's how we got here.
- reaperducer 8y agoWhy is the US so set on voting machine to begin with? George Bush vs. Al Gore and the hanging chads. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2000_United_States_presidential_election_recount_in_Florida https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2000_United_States_presidentia... After the election the rallying cry was the losing side was that the human factor should be eliminated in order to have pristine elections. Of course, we all know that electronic voting machines are still made by humans.
- pjc50 8y agoSome parts of the US have achieved banana-republic levels of corruption where the people getting elected go and work for the voting machine company and vice versa. https://medium.com/@jennycohn1/georgia-6-and-the-voting-machine-vendors-87278fdb0cdf https://medium.com/@jennycohn1/georgia-6-and-the-voting-mach...