3 ms·
It appears that MS made a major design effort when they designed the "Windows 95" look and feel. They produced a number of coherent concepts and tried to stick
by nine_k 8y ago
It appears that MS made a major design effort when they designed the "Windows 95" look and feel. They produced a number of coherent concepts and tried to stick to them everywhere. They kept the amount of fluff at bay.
It also appears that since then, they've never made an equivalent re-design effort to produce a coherent design and stick to it. XP was mostly an incremental change + re-skinning. Win 10 looks haphazard, unfortunately, and, most of all, the new UI is only applied sparsely, so you can't expect it to be equally usable everywhere.
A Linux desktop circa 2000 could have a hodge-podge of GUI programs based on of GTK, Motif, and Athena widgets. But I could not expect the same in 2018 from Microsoft's flagship desktop OS.
- jamesgeck0 8y agoEvery desktop environment is a hodgepodge of inconsistent UI design at this point. Windows has never been completely consistent; IIRC even Windows 95 had some settings dialogs that came along from Windows 3.1. Linux has GTK, Qt, and several toolkits aping aping them with various levels of success. MacOS comes closest to uniformity, until you start paying attention to title bars or run popular 3rd party applications on it.
- nine_k 8y agoOn Linux (and, generally, under X), you at least have copycat skinning engines, so that you can have your Qt programs mostly copy the look of the current GTK theme, and vice versa. Under Windows, no such thing existed and exists, unfortunately. One thing that I had hoped when installing Win 95 back in the day is that old binaries that use standard window-drawing functions will automatically upgrade to the new look and feel. Not all of them did, alas.
- eropple 8y agoCopy the look, for sure, but not the feel. If the spacing is still wrong or the keyboard shortcuts are messed up, it's not really materially better.
- maxxxxx 8y agoAgreed. Windows 95 was really well thought out and mostly consistent. I think MS went off the rails when Office started introducing its own UI concepts like the ribbon that were not available anywhere else. Then Win 8 had that weird split between Metro UI and regular Windows. I still find it hard to believe that they couldn't produce a consistent control panel for Win 10. I never know where to find certain settings. They could be hidden in the new UI or the old. Who knows? I also don't like the look of the UWP apps. Their rendering doesn't look very polished to me.
- byproxy 8y agoUWP programs seem so damn unresponsive, to me. I think part of it is excessive animations. Compare the right-click dropdown in Edge to that in Firefox, for example. Maybe if there were some setting where I could set the speed of those animations it wouldn't be so bad. But, for now, these UWP suffer from a very sluggish feeling.
- ummonk 8y agoI haven't been able to figure out how to do very basic network settings stuff in the new settings UI. Keep having to open the classic control panel.
- maxxxxx 8y agoI don't think there is much you can do in the new panel. I always pop back into the classic panel. But then there are other things that only the new panel can do :)
- toast0 8y ago> It appears that MS made a major design effort when they designed the "Windows 95" look and feel. They produced a number of coherent concepts and tried to stick to them everywhere. They kept the amount of fluff at bay. The key thing is it wasn't just a design effort -- they did a huge amount of human design research, and they published at least some amount of documentation about that. I haven't really seen anything similar since, but I would love to be pleasantly surprised with something to read. Everything else since doesn't feel like there was that much research behind it, and clearly nobody was convinced enough to fix up almost everything. Yes, windows 95 left a couple old style dialogs in the depths, but it was pretty complete.
- jodrellblank 8y agoNot sure if this will count, but ~2007 era when the Office Ribbon came out, Jensen Harris had a running blog series about the design of the ribbon. It's so often criticised that people think it was just dreamed up in a couple of hours, but there was real design and usability testing involved. https://blogs.msdn.microsoft.com/jensenh/2006/11/10/the-office-2007-ui-bible/ https://blogs.msdn.microsoft.com/jensenh/2006/11/10/the-offi... but, of course, the internet is ephemeral and all the images seem to be dead, and the Wayback machine doesn't have it.