3 ms·
Using “they” in the manner he describes, and gives examples of, is indeed wrong. But that does not mean that it’s bad, it only means that using “they” is not a
by teddyh 8y ago
Using “they” in the manner he describes, and gives examples of, is indeed wrong. But that does not mean that it’s bad, it only means that using “they” is not a drop-in replacement for traditional gendered pronouns. Using “they”, you simply have to construct your sentences so as to avoid any ambiguity.
English speakers managed this transition once before with the abandonment of “thou” – many sentences which were previously comprehensible with “thou” would be unclear or downright misleading if “thou” were simply replaced with “you”. But the modern speaker has no problems with using only “you”. Why? It’s because they are aware of the ambiguity and structure their sentences accordingly.
Don’t simply treat “they” as a drop-in replacement, just use it, and get used to writing a bit differently. Yes, it’s a slightly different language that what you were used to. Languages change.