5 ms·
I haven't done much Blu-ray ripping, but I try to keep an eye on it to make sure it's still "working" as a thing. I want a movie collection, but I don't want to
by ocdtrekkie 8y ago
I haven't done much Blu-ray ripping, but I try to keep an eye on it to make sure it's still "working" as a thing. I want a movie collection, but I don't want to invest heavily in maintaining a RAID array of live drives to store giant 25 GB archives of each movie. I'd much rather just hang onto the Blu-ray discs, and know that inevitably they all get cracked, so I'll always have ripping options if I need it.
As a physical disc you can keep in your possession, it's still really the only way to "own" a movie these days. Vudu is nice, and I'll do a lot of casual watching via my digital copy codes, but the discs are my "collection".
- mrec 8y agoBlu-Ray rips from Handbrake etc aren't the raw on-disc encoding, and aren't actually that big. ~2-3GB is typical with decent quality. Often the filesize is surprisingly close to that from a DVD, presumably because the DVD one is encoding a bunch of unwanted compression artifacts.
- sigi45 8y agoBecause a DVD is using mpeg2 and Handbreak uses x.264
- mrec 8y agoNo, I'm comparing re-encoded rips to mp4 from both DVD and BD, both via Handbrake, both using H.264.
- sigi45 8y agoOkay; But in that case i'm not really sure how you rip your DVDs. H.264 for DVD and that low resolution doesn't need 2-3 Gig at all. Sure audio is always an issue, can't do much there.
- mrec 8y agoI'm not saying the BD rips aren't bigger, just that they're nowhere near as much bigger as the resolution and quality improvements might suggest. So BD averages maybe 2.5 GB, and DVD averages maybe 1.5 GB, while a BD frame has nearly 7 times as many pixels. I do set CQ a couple of stops higher for DVD, as per Handbrake recommendations, just because DVD has to get enlarged so much when watching fullscreen.
- sigi45 8y agoYou can see the difference between Blu-ray and streaming. Streaming has similar bitrates than what you get when you reduce a BD down to 2-3 Gig. It still looks good for sure but if I would buy the disk I would not reduce it as strong as 2-3. Perhaps 10gb.
- bscphil 8y ago2.5 GB will give you terrible picture quality for a Bluray. Even streaming from Amazon or Netflix will be 5-6 GB for a two hour movie, and those are usually just passable.
- mrec 8y agoEh, I'm old, I can remember watching VHS and doing graphics at 320x256, my eyesight's not what it was, and I'm playing these things on a 7-year old laptop. That "terrible picture quality" does me fine.
- aidenn0 8y agoA WD 4TB external drive can store 160 25TB blurays for $100. That adds a "tax" of $1.60 per disc if you rip the raw disc. I tend to re-encode as libx265 (preset veryslow CRF=18) which is a fairly transparent reencode at 20-40% the size, which lowers the storage cost to under $1 per disc. If you also have backups, that will double the cost, or you can accept the risk and re-rip them if you lose the drive. [edit] They have 6TB and 8TB options now that are cheaper per-disc if you have more than 160 bluray movies.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoOr I could just get the disc off the shelf and pop it in the drive on the rare occasion I want to watch it. What's the benefit to spend the time ripping it? Like, I manage an ebook library, and I easily spend more time and effort managing said ebook library than I actually spend reading the ebooks. So I'm hesitant to bring myself into movie library management when I have a fairly robust physical storage medium already handy.
- veridies 8y agoKodi has a great interface for browsing movies, and automatically tags things like director, year, nationality, and summary. My fiancée likes to flip through that to pick things to watch; it's a lot easier and faster than trying to figure out all those details from the backs of BDs, which often make it very difficult to even see the duration of a film. And it allows me to mix together video files from BDs and DVDs with files from other sources (a lot of which are commercially unavailable, such as an Ethiopian film which has never been released except on VHS and a version of The Umbrellas of Cherbourg which has been modified to fix a color error) into one seamless interface. Obviously, though, this is just what works for me. If physical BDs are easier then by all means go for it.
- aidenn0 8y agoIf you spend more time managing your ebook library than reading your ebooks, then this might not be for you. I have ~100 ebooks and it's "load in calibre then forget about it until I want to read" Movies took me slightly longer as while (Author, Title) is unique for books, (Title) is not. More recently I discovered (Title, Year) is near enough to unique that I can name my rips that and Kodi is happy.