6 ms·
Oh great, yet another measure that will disproportionally affect the poor the most. Rich people either have enough money to not care about this tax, or can aff
by mschuster91 8y ago
Oh great, yet another measure that will disproportionally affect the poor the most.
Rich people either have enough money to not care about this tax, or can afford homes close to their place of work, while poor people have to endure long commutes to get to work.
- manojlds 8y agoShould do the lottery like China does.
- rdiddly 8y agoWhat expense is that not true of? Owning the car in the first place is harder on the poor.
- ForrestN 8y agoGraduated income tax. Simplify the tax code, make the curve steeper, get rid of sales and usage taxes unless there is truly no benefit (like tobacco). (In my opinion)
- isostatic 8y agoWhy would you peanalise productive people through income tax? Why do you want to discourage working? Only way to rescue is to get paid less, not something we want to encourage. Why not tax land value instead, easy to reduce by making better use of the land, which is something we want to encourage. Taxing gas is still important to reclaim some of the externalities that burning it causes. Same with taxing alcohol which leads to societal problems.
- ForrestN 8y agoDo you have evidence that increasing taxes on people earning more than, say, $1M per year "discourages working?" I also support taxing land value, but I don't think it's a replacement for graduated income tax. I mentioned tobacco, and alcohol is obviously similar. But with gas, there are poorer people who simply cannot opt out of using gas. Maybe we should apply more tax to companies that produce or sell gas instead?
- isostatic 8y agoAt a $1m/year level you're just discouraging gaining money via the work process and instead gaining money elsewhere. This is already discouraged (people earning $2m/year can afford to pay an accountancy firm $50k to restructure their income via offshoring or capital gains, even if they only save 10% tax on the top million) One common wheeze is to funnel your income into a company and then take loans (including services) from it. There's an entire industry built around reducing income tax, which leads to massive tax laws to It's quite easy to reduce gas usage -- stop buying gas guzzling cars. 25mpg (that's 30mpg in the UK) is a terrible 'average fuel economy' [0], especially based on official figures. Buy a Skoda Citigo which gets a real 50mpg (us gallons) [1] We have poor people in the UK too, and they have to pay for gas, yet manage to cope with gas tax of 314 cents per (us) gallon. At an average 25mpg and 3.2 trillion miles a year in the US [2], that's 128 billion gallons. Increase your current gas tax of about 50c/gallon [3] to say $1.50 a gallon -- still under half what we pay in europe. That would raise an extra $100b a year which could be distributed evenly to all 320 million U.S. citizens, a $300/year flat payment, enough to offset the extra gas tax of 7500 miles, or for a 4 person family, 30,000 miles. This would discourage gas guzzling cars (you save a lot more by buying a car with a higher mpg) and not harm the people who "can't opt out of using gas". [0] https://phys.org/news/2016-11-average-fuel-economy-high-mpg.html https://phys.org/news/2016-11-average-fuel-economy-high-mpg.... [1] https://www.honestjohn.co.uk/topten/top-10-the-best-petrol-real-mpg-car/?image=1 https://www.honestjohn.co.uk/topten/top-10-the-best-petrol-r... [2] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M12MTVUSM227NFWA/ https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M12MTVUSM227NFWA/ [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_taxes_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_taxes_in_the_United_State...
- ForrestN 8y agoWe should make these dishonest tax evasion schemes illegal or find other ways to break them. I'd be happy to support gas-guzzling car taxes, or even increasingly intense efficiency regulations for cars. But a straight tax on gasoline punishes poor people who probably can't afford to buy another car or move to somewhere more central.
- jedberg 8y agoI assume it we would get rid of some of the gas tax in exchange, in which case this would be a wash for the poor. I also assume it would be a tax based not only on miles but the value of the car, such that cheaper/lighter cars would get taxed less, which would help defray costs to the poor. But you're right, in the end the tax would necessarily be regressive, which pretty much every usage based tax is.
- ForrestN 8y agoThis. I'm for increasing taxes to Denmark levels but these schemes make income inequality worse, not better. And the fact that this will most hurt commuters, who are already struggling given crazy housing prices, is especially sad.
- prostoalex 8y agoOn the other hand, commuters will think twice before accepting a job offer that requires a multiple-hour commute. That will increase the pressure on local governments to provide adequate public transportation. It will also increase the pressure on private markets to couple office tower developments with apartment high-rises versus the current models for most US cities - all offices downtown, all residences in suburbs. It will increase pressure on employers to provide more diverse and distributed options versus "everybody be in the main office tower by 8 a.m.".
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- closeparen 8y agoSuburban sprawl is exactly as required by law, from the mutually exclusive land uses right down to the paint on the strip-mall parking lots. Market forces would love to build walkable mixed-use districts. A proud tradition of highly effective grassroots activism makes sure that they don't. You may find this talk [0], or the speaker's book Suburban Nation, enlightening. It's not at all the case that market forces need to be adjusted here. It's public policy which is broken. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NMvwHDFVpCE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NMvwHDFVpCE
- raldi 8y agoActually, the poor drive the least. Subsidies on driving disproportionately benefit the well-off. Done right, a tax like this would be revenue-neutral, and enacted alongside a reduction in some regressive tax, like sales tax. The winners are poor people and people who don't drive. The losers, well-off people who drive.
- closeparen 8y agoThat’s absurd. You really think it’s the rich commuting 2+ hours each way from the Central Valley far out of public transit range, and the poor paying $5000/mo for walkable urban high rises? San Francisco’s amenities can only exist because subsidized car infrastructure makes it possible to get here from affordable places, however painfully. Your walkable grocery store’s shelves don’t get stocked without highways and sprawl. The walkabale radius around any BART stop is thoroughly into tech-workers-only price ranges by now (or truly terrifying).
- raldi 8y agoYou're afflicted right now by one of those beliefs that is simultaneously obvious, intuitive, and completely false. See http://www.ppic.org/content/pubs/report/R_704LRR.pdf http://www.ppic.org/content/pubs/report/R_704LRR.pdf for instance: "[In the Bay Area,] Low-income workers walk, carpool, and use public transit at higher rates than their more affluent counterparts". And on page 86 you can see that 70% of high-income folks drive alone to work. Amongst poor people (their term), it's 51%. Meanwhile, 5% of high-income residents of the Bay Area take the bus to work. Amongst poor people, 12%.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- closeparen 8y agoThat's from 2004. The contemporary story of gentrification is higher-income workers choosing the urban core, and lower-income workers getting pushed to the suburban periphery where adequate transit coverage is less likely. The relevant quantity here is vehicle mileage, not mode share. I expected lower-income workers to drive much longer distances (whereas the rich would have more car trips but trivial distances). So I'm more interested in "Other research suggests that low-income workers travel shorter distances than other workers" which is genuinely surprising. I wonder how that's fared over time. [0] Page ix
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Oh great, yet another measure that will disproportionally affect the poor the most. Transferring some portion of road maintenance funding from the gas tax (which the rich buy their way into lower per-mile charges for by paying more up front for hybrid and electric vehicles) to a mileage tax doesn't disproportionately affect the poor, at least not in terms of adverse effects.