6 ms·
Why pennies cost more than they're worth
- mattew 16y agoA penny is "worth" one cent in that it is the value it represents. However, it can be exchanged many times contributing value in each exchange. Also, there are many other coins that likely cost less to mint than they are "worth". I think you need to look at the overall cost of minting for all coins and blend it together to get a more accurate view.
- bhc3 16y agoThat's along the lines of what I was thinking too. The cost of making a penny isn't really material to the fact that it's worth 1 cent. That'd only be relevant if pennies were used one time, which then would be an issue. But pennies are re-used multiple times. So a cost of two cents is fine when you consider that. Now a better question to ask is what are the transactional costs of maintaining prices that require pennies (as oppose to, say, 5 cent increments). Those costs are the better ones to look at, I think.
- hugh3 16y agoBut pennies are re-used multiple times. So a cost of two cents is fine when you consider that. Right, until you get to the point where the metal inside a penny is worth so much more than the face value that it becomes worthwhile for somebody to start melting them down. Luckily that doesn't seem to be the case yet (at least not with the new-denomination pennies). They're still pointless coins, though. Get rid of them.
- maeon3 16y agoPre 1982 pennies are worth like 2 or 3 cents melted down I believe. They are becoming more and more rare because they are made of copper, a valuable resource. The federal reserve is printing money out of thin air and diluting the currency more than ever. This means that as we move forward, too many dollars are going to chase too few goods and the prices will rise. Eventually if this grand theft is left to continue without limit, the Federal reserve will print so many dollars that one day even the paper fabric of the money will become worth more than what you can buy with it. Nickels are worth about 6 cents I recall. Don't get caught melting down pennies or Nickels for the guaranteed profit because it is a crime. However, as inflation continues, the value of the materials in the coins will rise to infinity, at that point all coins will mysteriously vanish and the mint will not make new ones. They will instead add zeros to the dollar bills. Buy gold, it's going to $5000 an ounce in the next year. Gold is flatline, it is a stable store of value, the gold is not gaining value, it's the unit of measure you're using that is depreciating.
- mey 16y agoGold is not flatline, nor stable, especially when adjusted for inflation (CPI-U). Gold, like money, is based on faith. People expect it is a limited resource, but in reality, the price of gold simply hasn't always been at a point where it is profitable to mine more of it. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Gold_price_in_USD.png http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Gold_price_in_USD.png http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold_as_an_investment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold_as_an_investment
- maeon3 16y agoYour correct it is not flat, it's value is modified by how much gold can be mined by companies. Also it is modified by how many people want the metal itself. What I meant to say that if you worked hard for a year 200 years ago and saved yourself maybe 10 ounces of gold, and buried it in the ground for 200 years and now you have those 10 ounces. The goods and services you could buy between then and now would be comparable. whereas the various currencies he used 200 years ago would be either completely worthless or decreased in value 99.99%. Gold is going to be around for another 50 years, and you'll be able to buy things with it. The US Dollar however is not. When I say gold is flatline, I mean that in principle a ounce of gold saved will buy you nice things 50 years from now, a thousand dollars now will buy you nothing 50 years from now.
- hugh3 16y agoGold is going to be around for another 50 years, and you'll be able to buy things with it. The US Dollar however is not. I'll tell you what I tell everybody who thinks there's going to be US Dollar hyperinflation: I bet you a trillion dollars that's not going to happen. Seriously though, predictions are tricky, especially about the future. It may be worth injecting a tone of a little more uncertainty into your pronouncements about what's going to happen in the future. Personally I'd have less confidence in the buried gold or the buried dollars than I would about the value of the land you're burying it under.
- crpatino 16y agoThe belief that gold holds an intrinsic value is wrong, and the advice you derive from it is incredibly misguided. There's nothing special about gold. It has some nice properties that make it intrinsically valuable, but not more than copper or other metals. The reason basically all cultures value gold is that other people like it also, and it is hard to counterfeit. That being said, gold goes through the same ups and downs in perceived value as any other commodity. For what I have read, it is trading now more or less around its long term historic value (think centuries long). If there's so much buzz about gold now, it is because it is coming from a few decades long of sub-valuation, but this is correcting fast, and the pendulum begins to swing now to the other side. If you are not able to pick your time correctly, you'll be loosing money soon enough. Besides, there is the fact that it is a long time investment. If you are forced to liquidate your position to pay whatever need you have, you will probably loose money. And there's the commissions that will eat out on each transaction, so you better hold to gold until it is a really good time to sell.
- ryandvm 16y agoWhenever I hear the phrase "a penny saved is a penny earned", I like to point out that if you do a back of the envelope calculation for inflation you'll come up with a penny being worth approximately $5 when Benjamin Franklin made his famous quote. He probably would have thought us to be morons for hand-wringing over a few cents.
- hugh3 16y agoIs that so? I find it hard to imagine a currency in which the smallest denomination available is the equivalent of five dollars. If you're inventing a new currency from scratch, why not have a smaller minimum denomination?
- pavel_lishin 16y agoMaybe there wasn't much you could buy for less than $5. What's a single Zimbabwe dollar going to get you? Nothin'.
- hugh3 16y agoIn which case, in what sense was it worth five dollars? If you tell me that something is worth five dollars then I'm going to expect to, for instance, be able to get two loaves of bread for it. Or maybe half an hour's work from an unskilled labourer. Of course the conversion ratio between loaves and hours was different then (I assume bread is a lot cheaper/labour is more expensive) which is why we can't really convert between today's money and the money of the 1770s.
- jws 16y agoThere were half pennies and farthings (quarter pennies). Once the US got done with revolting and got around to writing a constitution they decreed the "mill" would be 1/10th of a penny. They seem to have largely only useful for sales tax. I think a smaller coin would have been impractical: • Coins were self-backing with their metal value. Even in copper, it gets too small to keep track. • Manufacture was more labor intensive, the cost to produce a very low coin is a problem. • Mass production hadn't devalued objects, so things we think of as cheap today would have been relatively more expensive. • If you live in a small community and "run a tab" at the general store, you don't make payment in small batches. None of these speculations should be mistaken for accurate historical facts.
- kijinbear 16y agoWould have been more interesting if there were numbers attached to each step of the minting process. For example, +0.05 cents for stamping, -0.1 cents for recycling damaged coins, etc.
- Semiapies 16y agoA penny is pretty much negative money, if you care about the debt. I see no major problem with getting rid of it - other countries have, after all. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swedish_rounding http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swedish_rounding