3 ms·
It's very crudely stated, but there's a bit of a truth to it. Suppose that "susceptibility to opioid abuse" is a trait that's distributed throughout the popula
by philwelch 8y ago
It's very crudely stated, but there's a bit of a truth to it.
Suppose that "susceptibility to opioid abuse" is a trait that's distributed throughout the population; some people are very susceptible, and some people are not very susceptible, but there's still an independent, individual factor that is separate from e.g. cultural/economic/social angst/uncertainty/etc., the availability of opioids, and so forth.
When there is a breakthrough in one of these external social factors--either opioids become a lot cheaper and more available, people slip into greater levels of despair, whatever--more people are going to abuse opioids. Fair enough. But not everyone is equally likely to abuse opioids even given the exact same circumstances, so most of this increase in opioid abuse will be concentrated in the chunk of the population that was more susceptible to it all along.
Once the opioid epidemic goes on for a few years, the people most likely to abuse opioids--and, for that matter, the people most likely to die from opioid abuse--will die. And so, if the underlying social causes of opioid abuse stay the same, you're going to see fewer opioid deaths, because the people who would have died already have.
Since this isn't necessarily a genetic trait, we probably wouldn't see this effect persist on the order of generations, but on the order of months to years there's definitely a survivor bias, so to speak.
There isn't necessarily any moral judgment in here, either. I mean, there can be, if you're a jerk about it, but the math itself doesn't work out any differently for "susceptibility to opioid addiction" than it does for "susceptibility to flu", and so if there's an epidemic of either one of those, odds are that, barring intervention, the epidemic is going to kill whoever it's going to kill and then move on. (This isn't cause for complacency, either! Some epidemics can kill huge supermajorities of the population if you just let them play themselves out, which is the true story of how the West[ern Hemisphere] was won.)