2 ms·
I'm not sure I can take it anymore. Websites are just getting too complicated to design and build. First it was desktop with mouse -- easy. Then responsive des
by crazygringo 8y ago
I'm not sure I can take it anymore. Websites are just getting too complicated to design and build.
First it was desktop with mouse -- easy. Then responsive design requiring both desktop and mobile layouts, as well as interaction design with both mouse and touch. Now what if users start expecting both light and dark versions of websites? "We show the mobile version of the menu with its own hover on small screens only, but the hover only appears if JavaScript detects a mouse, but wait we need a different hover color when it's in dark mode!"
Not to mention other standard things like making sure it works in all major browsers, or even that interactive things like comments or voting have non-JavaScript fallbacks, or that the order of elements is appropriate for screenreaders.
I love using dark mode at night, and as a user would love for every website to follow it too. But as a developer, there are just too many combinations to design and test for, and it's growing exponentially!
- lostgame 8y agoI think the largest issue with this is it is currently a Safari-only, and an early Safari-only release at that. And that the latest MacOS right now is the only major commercial OS offering a dark theme to the extent that it does. A quick look at Safari's desktop browser market share reveals it to be about 4% right now. When this kind of standard makes its way into Chrome and/or FF, it'll be relevant. Until then, it's a toy, and nothing more. Nobody could ever realistically expect this kind of thing. It doesn't increase the complexity of web design by that much. If you think adding CSS exceptions for inverted colours is the straw that broke the camel's back on web complexity for you, perhaps you just feel like we should've stuck with the late 90's or worse, early 00's web standards? Many websites, even YouTube, already have a 'night' or 'dark' switch. It makes a lot of sense, and genuinely is not that hard to implement.
- saagarjha 8y agoChrome and Firefox might end up implementing this to serve their users on macOS.
- nine_k 8y agoMultiple alternative CSS files were a thing in early 2000s. But browsers never developed support for them. Now some sites offer switchable "themes", tough.
- 3pt14159 8y agoWebsites aren't really getting complicated to design if you treat them the way they were originally designed: As a network of documents. It's once you try to app-ify them that things break down. Though really, with this new dark mode I just wish I could set a max whitepoint. I code in the dark but too much of the web is bright and I constantly have to change my brightness going between the two. I don't want a third party pluggin. I just want Apple to do it. The have it on the iPhone and it works great there.
- mixmastamyk 8y agoYes, most folks forget the original background color of the web was #ccc with black text. Readable day or night.