3 ms·
Thank you for writing this comment so that I don't feel like a crazy person after reading this article. It came across to me as so obviously flawed that it's ha
by munificent 8y ago
Thank you for writing this comment so that I don't feel like a crazy person after reading this article. It came across to me as so obviously flawed that it's hard to even apply Hanlon's Razor to it.
Not once does he mention of any correction for the obvious bias that people make different amounts at different points in their careers.
Using his exact same process, you could also show that the average height of Americans has increased significantly in the past thirty years, possibly up to a foot! Because, duh, people are shorter when they're kids.
If you're trying to measure how the economy is doing over time, you don't want panels, you want to compare equivalent people at different points in time. Comparing a 20 year old in 1980 to a 50 year old in 2010 confounds the differences between 1980 and 2010 with the differences between being 20 and being 50.
There are reasonable criticisms that identifying representative "equal" people over time is hard, but the author's solution seems dramatically worse than all of them.
- tanderson92 8y agoOne huge blind spot in using panel data over a 34 year period is that a lot of the people you are initially looking at are retired, and so do not typically pay as much tax or otherwise need to make the same amount of income to have the same standard of living. The article is very poorly framed and argued.
- lgats 8y agoHanlon's razor is an aphorism expressed in various ways, including: Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanlon%27s_razor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanlon%27s_razor
- chrismanfrank 8y agoFrom the article: "The study looks at people who were 35–40 in 1987 and then looks at how they were doing 20 years later, when they are 55–60. The median income of the people in the top 20% in 1987 ended up 5% lower twenty years later. The people in the middle 20% ended up with median income that was 27% higher. And if you started in the bottom 20%, your income doubled. If you were in the top 1% in 1987, 20 years later, median income was 29% lower."
- crazygringo 8y agoIn other words, regression to the mean. Of course the poorest people are more likely to gain in income -- when you start at the bottom, there's really only one direction you can go. You can still have regression to the mean among individuals while society itself is becoming horrifyingly unequal.
- snikeris 8y agoWould you please elaborate on this: > society itself is becoming horrifyingly unequal
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agohttps://www.cnbc.com/2018/07/19/income-inequality-continues-to-grow-in-the-united-states.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/07/19/income-inequality-continues-... https://inequality.stanford.edu/publications/20-facts-about-us-inequality-everyone-should-know https://inequality.stanford.edu/publications/20-facts-about-... https://www.businessinsider.com/inequality-is-deepening-us-economic-weakness-by-fracturing-society-2018-3 https://www.businessinsider.com/inequality-is-deepening-us-e... Will that do, or do you need more elaboration?
- snikeris 8y agoThanks, I'll check these out. Inequality seems like a fact of life, so I'm wondering what's so horrifying about it. Edit: I was really hopeful for this Stanford resource, but I'm not even sure these "are facts that everyone should know". > 10. Residential Segregation tldr: Rich people and poor people don't live in the same areas. > 13. Bad Jobs tldr: Some people have bad jobs, and if you don't work full-time somewhere you're more likely to have a bad job. This just seems like common sense. Was anyone surprised by this? Certainly not horrified.
- JustSomeNobody 8y agoNot horrifying: When your refrigerator dies and you can go buy another without blinking. Horrifying: When you misplace a $20 bill and now you can't pay your rent. It's really simple to understand.
- Chris_Chambers 8y agoThe author of this article is a Jew.