4 ms·
> Surprise! Over 30 years poor people gained an average of almost $30k in income! I sure fucking hope someone who started at minimum wage in 1980 is making $30k
by pwaivers 8y ago
> Surprise! Over 30 years poor people gained an average of almost $30k in income! I sure fucking hope someone who started at minimum wage in 1980 is making $30k more today.
Well this is an important part of his argument. The people's wages are not stagnant, but rather they went up an 30K (including inflation). That fact this their wages went up is not trivial.
- scarmig 8y agoNot to the overall structure of the economy. Imagine this: at one high school, there's a 80% literacy rate in the 2008 class. Then it drops to a 60% rate for the 2018 class. Even if the 2008 cohort may now have a 90% literacy rate, that doesn't change the fact that the school is declining in literacy, and trying to argue otherwise verges on duplicitous.
- munificent 8y agoBut that's not a useful fact. People are going to get older regardless of what economic policy choices you make, so observing that people go through economic changes as they age isn't actionable. By analogy, if you're trying to choose effective dietary policy, a study that shows people got taller over the past twenty years isn't helpful if you measure the same people. All it shows you is that children grow larger as they become adults.
- refurb 8y agoWhat is the connection between aging and wages? Sure, most people make more money when they get older, but this was looking at ~40 to retirement when people are already at their peak earnings. I wouldn't take it for granted that the older you are the more you make.