3 ms·
People are afraid of stuff they don't know about. Most of us work in offices and don't even own a 3/8 socket set. (Of course they have no problem with some dud
by dsfyu404ed 8y ago
People are afraid of stuff they don't know about. Most of us work in offices and don't even own a 3/8 socket set. (Of course they have no problem with some dude who barely reads English, or whatever language the service literature is in, performing service on their vehicle because he's a "professional"). There's also the fact that with physical objects you can't just revert them if you do it wrong like you can with code. People here are used to having that capability. Working with things where you don't have a near-zero cost option to revert is going to make a lot of people here uneasy. There's a vocal minority here who just hates cars to begin with and has no problem saying things that feed those fears. Then there's the fact that lot of people here are afraid of liability so they start going crazy when any entity that isn't a multi-million dollar company they can sue starts modifying anything tangentially involving safety even if the risks involved are on the order of being eaten by a shark on dry land in Kansas.
Tl;DR the subject matter and the user-base of HN react in a way that brings out more negativity than each one could normally on its own.
- mikeash 8y agoThis isn’t my story, I’m just an early upvoter hoping to come back to find interesting commentary instead of a bunch of whining. I think your assessment is correct. Adding even more negativity to the mix, a lot of HN users are skeptical of Tesla in general and Autopilot in particular.
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>Adding even more negativity to the mix, a lot of HN users are skeptical of Tesla in general and Autopilot in particular. With autopilot in particular we know how that sausage is made.
- danso 8y agoAutopilot continues to be advertised [0] as if it were fully or even near-autonomous driving, so I think those of us who know better are reasonable to start from a position of skepticism. [0] https://www.tesla.com/autopilot https://www.tesla.com/autopilot
- mikeash 8y agoI don’t see how Autopilot marketing is at all relevant here.
- alibarber 8y agoGives a whole new meaning to 'move fast and break things'. But seriously I find the backlash so interesting and I think it is mainly for the reasons you describe. We all know how bug-laden much of the software that's shipped is, but it doesn't really matter because (for the most part) it's easy to iterate, issue an update - to the point that people who run un-updated software are considered foolish, etc etc. I think we should remember that actual _engineers_ are out there who design and make the bridges, cars and buildings that keep us alive who don't have this luxury. This guy seems like one of them and is clearly skilled (you can see that his workmanship looks good and he's taking care in these photos) and should be respected in my opinion.
- j2bax 8y agoI'm not sure I understand why someones English reading comprehension should matter when it comes to servicing a vehicle if they are an experienced mechanic at a reputable shop.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoBecause that's the language that service literature in the US typically available in. In my opinion literacy at all is optional for 99.9% of automotive work but the kind of people who will pearl clutch over an enthusiast rebuilding calipers in their garage will probably not be all that pleased to learn that it's not uncommon for someone who can barely read the service literature to be servicing vehicles and I thought it was worth mentioning.