4 ms·
> The reason the whole idea of color and whiteness was presented was to answer the question of why did people remove the color from the objects Extremely uncon
by lmm 8y ago
> The reason the whole idea of color and whiteness was presented was to answer the question of why did people remove the color from the objects
Extremely unconvincingly, though; the linguistic accident that we use the same word ("white") to describe a shade and an ethnicity is doing most of the rhetorical work. None of the reconstructions shown in the article looks particularly "non-white". Doesn't it seem more plausible that people removed traces of colours because, as even the article acknowledges, they make the statues look gaudy and childish?
- iguy 8y agoIt is a bit strange how the article veers between ethnicity and paint. I mean both are interesting, but the fact that we came to think of the naked marble of these statues as the canonical version seems largely unrelated to whether the greeks were, well, greek. (And to other questions, like how did their society think about these things, and how much has post-classical migration changed the makeup of the people living there. IIRC the African component of North-Africans has increased a bit.) There is one picture in TFA of an African-looking child. And interestingly they say that this effect was often conveyed by choosing to work in basalt, as well as painting with darker colors. I guess these must be fairly uncommon, I can't recall seeing any in museums?
- yourbandsucks 8y agoThe skin tone of Greeks themselves got a huge injection of germanic whiteness after Rome fell and the Italy was taken over by Lombards and Normans.
- iguy 8y agoIndeed. And of course some of what was Greece has now became Turkey, and for which enough Turks must have shown up to switch the language... I don't know the current data here but I'm sure it's improving rapidly.
- baldfat 8y agoIt was a response to this research why there is a political tone: > She is not the only classicist who has been targeted by the so-called alt-right. Some white supremacists have been drawn to classical studies out of a desire to affirm what they imagine to be an unblemished lineage of white Western culture extending back to ancient Greece. > None of the reconstructions shown in the article looks particularly "non-white". Your mixing modern and ancient ideas. The issue is how the Greeks viewed pale skin. This is not about how they were not "white" but that in Ancient Greece there was no pro-bias for white over dark skin. "Nor did the Greeks conceive of race the way we do. Some of the ancients’ racial theories were derived from the Hippocratic idea of the humors. Rebecca Futo Kennedy, a classicist at Denison University, who writes on race and ethnicity, told me, “Cold weather made you stupid but also courageous, so that was what people from the Far North were supposed to be like. And the people they called Ethiopians were thought of as very smart but cowardly. It comes out of the medical tradition." "Pale skin on a woman was considered a sign of beauty and refinement, because it showed that she was privileged enough not to have to work outdoors. But a man with pale skin was considered unmasculine: bronzed skin was associated with the heroes who fought on battlefields and competed as athletes, naked, in amphitheatres."
- lmm 8y ago> Your mixing modern and ancient ideas. The article itself is doing that. "it was time we all accepted that ancient sculpture was not pure white—and neither were the people of the ancient world. One false notion, she said, had reinforced the other" - but how so? "Some white supremacists have been drawn to classical studies out of a desire to affirm what they imagine to be an unblemished lineage of white Western culture extending back to ancient Greece" - but none of the reconstructions the article shows would threaten such an affirmation. > a man with pale skin was considered unmasculine: bronzed skin was associated with the heroes who fought on battlefields and competed as athletes, naked, in amphitheatres. This sounds like an attempt to make something out of nothing, particularly given the lack of an picture (in an article that's otherwise full of them) that would commit to what shade of "bronzed" they're actually talking about. Ancient Greeks thought men looked better with a tan? Sure, so do many modern people.
- 8y ago