3 ms·
I'm sure the budget for this new experiment will be given straight away, no questions asked. Though of course, there's a difference between "drug A doesn't wor
by raverbashing 8y ago
I'm sure the budget for this new experiment will be given straight away, no questions asked.
Though of course, there's a difference between "drug A doesn't work for condition B but seems to work slightly for C" and "drug A doesn't work for condition B but 10 of 12 individuals with condition C have shown significant improvement"
- AllegedAlec 8y ago> I'm sure the budget for this new experiment will be given straight away, no questions asked. Most of the cases: yes, although your example of clinical trials is slightly different, and in that case, I do think the data should be publicly available to other researchers even in the case of a null.
- xamuel 8y agoIf the original experiment was large enough [1], you could almost always find some C such that "drug A doesn't work for condition B but 90% [2] of individuals with condition C showed significant improvement". In fact, you could replace [2] by a number arbitrarily close to 100% by increasing [1] accordingly.
- wpietri 8y agoIf the original experiment was large enough to do that, then somebody was given way too much money for the original experiment. So I'd expect that's a very rare case.