6 ms·
"Your scientists were so preoccupied with whether or not they could, they didn’t stop to think if they should." As others have noted, this seems like a terribl
by jedberg 8y ago
"Your scientists were so preoccupied with whether or not they could, they didn’t stop to think if they should."
As others have noted, this seems like a terrible idea. One small mistake, and it could kill his wife, himself, or someone else on the road. All the other self driving Teslas have at least gone through testing to make sure they are road safe.
I know I'll be avoiding any yellow Teslas from now on!
- jdboyd 8y ago> One small mistake, and it could kill his wife, himself, or someone else on the road. I believe you have just described driving in general.
- vntok 8y agoNO it's way worse than driving in general, because once the car has been modified, its behaviour on the road and that of the guy in the driver seat are completely decorrelated. Ergo, the guy can be much more alert than most people on the road and STILL crash into others without any sort of warning, simply due to a software bug. For various reasons, in regular cars, this should not happen.
- extrapickles 8y agoIf they keep their hands on the wheel and the self driving actuators can’t overpower standard human strength, I would be fine with it on the road near me. It also looks like his workmanship was reasonable so he probably did everything correctly.
- vntok 8y ago> This required transplanting the controls from a salvage steering wheel, which had a blown airbag, into my wife’s steering wheel. Reusing delicate parts from a salvage wheel that had a blown airbag does not seem particularly safe to me. Then again, at least it only endangers his presumably consenting wife and not third party drivers/pedestrians on the road.
- LoSboccacc 8y agoWell except the one it will crash into.
- mschuster91 8y ago> Reusing delicate parts from a salvage wheel that had a blown airbag does not seem particularly safe to me. Why not? The one part that matters for safety in a wheel is not delicate at all: it's the connection to the axle. Even if all power is suddenly dead, the vehicle can still be manually controlled. As for the airbag, I guess (and hope) that the author did replace it.
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>Reusing delicate parts from a salvage wheel that had a blown airbag does not seem particularly safe to me. Well the existence of the entire used car parts industry seems to indicate otherwise. For some parts, especially out of production control modules over various kinds, used is the only option. Mechanical failure is a drop in the bucket in terms of road safety. Mechanical failure as a result of substandard parts (as opposed to deferred maintenance/repair) is such a small fraction of that drop I've never heard of anyone even trying to measure it specifically.
- tjoff 8y agoIf... The whole premise of tesla lane guidance is to allow for the driver to relax. This allows for the driver to not pay attention which in turns has caused several deaths. That is completely inevitable. Humans are just not capable of behaving rationally in such a system. These modifications increase that risk. These modifications do not increase the attentiveness of the driver. Step 3 ... Step 4: profit?
- ux-app 8y ago> "probably" ...
- mikeash 8y agoReally, “completely decorrelated”? Like, the driver will steer left, and the result will be for the car to open the rear window and brake? Come on.
- vntok 8y agoWho knows without QA? Jokes aside, yes my point was that the driver could be the best in the entire world, if the software has a critical bug the car could crash on its own volition. That just doesn't happen with regular cars. Even critical bugs like the "enforced uncontrolled acceleration while on the highway" scandal in the years 2005-2010s were eventually proven to be self-prophecy cases of human error meets FUD.
- King-Aaron 8y agoLet me describe to you the 900-kilogram car I'm building, with forged pistons and a turbo big enough to fit your head inside. It probably won't hold traction until third or fourth gear. One small mistake and it would kill all sorts of stakeholders. People like me drive highly modified cars day in, day out. Though I'd honestly trust the handiwork of someone who can figure out the sophistication behind a tesla and it's electronics more readily than I'd trust your general backyard mechanic. It's not uncommon to see 40 year old cars driving around with stock suspension and brakes, that have had a 6.2L LSx engine fitted (as an example). I'd be more concerned with those kinds of conversions before I'd worry about the one Tesla in the united states that has a jerry-rigged autopilot.
- swarnie_ 8y ago> Let me describe to you the 900-kilogram car I'm building, with forged pistons and a turbo big enough to fit your head inside. It probably won't hold traction until third or fourth gear. Sarcasm is hard to pick up via a written media so i'm going to assume you're legit. Where is this thing even legal to drive??
- function_seven 8y agoWhat he described sounds like a lot of street legal cars in the US. As long as it has turn signals, windshield wipers, seat belts, and some other things on a short list, it's allowed on the road. Here's one example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ariel_Atom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ariel_Atom EDIT: And another: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mazda_MX-5_(NA) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mazda_MX-5_(NA)
- King-Aaron 8y agoYeah not to mention guys like Saleen and Hennessey who make some downright ludicrous road cars. When you're talking about the power levels they make, the difference between 900kg and 1200kg is negligible :P https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hennessey_Venom_GT https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hennessey_Venom_GT Edit, and a more serious note, this is the flip side of the kinds of things we're discussing though. Not all modified cars are built to equal safety considerations, and not all modified car stories end well. https://jalopnik.com/man-dies-after-crash-in-home-built-honda-civic-based-ka-1825681533 https://jalopnik.com/man-dies-after-crash-in-home-built-hond...
- kurtisc 8y agoFor any accidents I can think of where this modification would cause an accident, the driver would have to sit back and let the autopilot do the driving: that's irresponsible in any car. Is there something else, like severing a drive-by-wire connection to the brakes, that I'm missing?
- Theodores 8y agoWhy is this his wife's car and not his? He has his own fancier Tesla, you would think that they would swap so she has the better car. The yellow colour is just a wrap, he could have had things cosmetically correct for her by wrapping his P95(D). Plus she would not have been off the road waiting for the homebrew modifications to happen. I am okay with people modifying their cars, in fact I like to go to the race tracks where people go at actually ludicrous speeds in their modified cars, repairing them between races. But it is a different thing modifying a car for someone else in an experimental way. On a track where the driver is a 'racing driver' is one thing but, on the highway when the driver is a 'civilian', well, that is something else. A small rattle means something to the guy who built it and knows what that rattle can be from, another 'civilian' driver won't necessarily know the problem space.
- mikeash 8y agoMaybe she likes her car?
- TomMarius 8y agoYou should also avoid any Openpilot-capable vehicle, then
- mikeash 8y agoThat “one small mistake” bit applies to driving almost any car in almost any circumstances. And yet we allow complete morons to drive them after passing a cursory test.
- ams6110 8y ago> All the other self driving Teslas have at least gone through testing to make sure they are road safe. Like the one that ran directly into a lane divider at highway speed? Or the one that ran into the side of a semi trailer?
- TomMarius 8y agoMy ACC/lane assist would do the same thing. Autopilot was never intended to be used without looking at the road. People have misconceptions about the word "autopilot" - it has never ever meant full or even partial autonomy, plane autopilots are way less autonomous than a basic ACC in a car is.
- gamblor956 8y agoMy ACC/lane assist would do the same thing. Citation needed. In the history of lane assist, Teslas are the only cars that have actually run into center dividers and killed their drivers while lane assist was engaged, because other automakers are sensible enough to disable lane assist where the lane markings are ambiguous.
- TomMarius 8y agoI drove some 2-door Volvo that almost sent me into a truck that was next to me in the middle of a turn on a highway. Actually it didn't work in any turns (as in did nothing, most of the time). Terrible thing, especially considering that there was absolutely no clear mark anywhere on the dashboard that it's enabled and I was driving 200 km/h (on autobahn in Germany) when the situation with a truck happened. I also never found out how to disable that thing, thankfully I didn't have to drive on the way home. I own a Ford Mondeo (the 2008 high end variant) and it would not disengage when marks on the right side disappear, left is enough - but that is a problem because it'll resist if I try to go to the right (if there is a split) and I guess that a very similar accident to the Tesla one could happen but we have no places like that around here so I can't test. I don't use the system.
- 8y ago