7 ms·
People are always so paranoid about autonomous cars, as if we expect cars and drivers to otherwise be infallible, contrary to all available evidence. People ha
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
People are always so paranoid about autonomous cars, as if we expect cars and drivers to otherwise be infallible, contrary to all available evidence.
People have been modifying their cars since there have been cars. Sometimes the modifications are problematic. Sometimes problems result in accidents. Those cases are rare. Moreover, since the modifications are all bespoke, the odd erroneous one affects only that single vehicle.
On the other hand, the modifications let people learn. It's how we get new ideas. That improve safety. For more than just one car.
- lwhi 8y agoIf the modifications a person makes have the potential to kill members of the public, I think you're wrong. This is new technology; laws and regulations need to reach a stage where they're able to protect against the worst from happening. People have to take driving tests. Is there an equivalent safeguard for an autonomous vehicle?
- postmeta 8y agoOr guns? /jk
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> If the modifications a person makes have the potential to kill members of the public, I think you're wrong. Literally everything has the potential to kill members of the public. A bug in your mobile device app could interact with a bug in the hardware and cause the battery to catch fire in the middle of the night and burn down an apartment building. If you install casters on the office copy machine, it may slide down an incline, through a 10th story window and kill someone in the street. > This is new technology; laws and regulations need to reach a stage where they're able to protect against the worst from happening. There are two classic methods of discouraging harm. The original, which works fine for low volume modifications, is that if you do something reckless you get held liable after the fact. The method you're proposing is to do safety testing ahead of time. But that is only reasonable for products that are mass produced. If you're going to make a million of something, it makes sense to analyze it ahead of time because the high fixed cost of doing that can be amortized over a million units whereas the amount of harm prevented is multiplied by a million units. That method is highly inefficient for one off modifications where the opposite is true.
- lwhi 8y agoI think you're greatly underestimating the danger involved.
- adrianN 8y agoThe complexity of "cars" has gone up exponentially over the years, so modifying them while still being reasonably sure that they're safe is getting harder. Today cars are at least as much software as hardware and it's completely unclear which assumptions are hardcoded into them that you could invalidate by modifications.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Today cars are at least as much software as hardware and it's completely unclear which assumptions are hardcoded into them that you could invalidate by modifications. This rings hollow as a novelty. If you replace the transmission with one that has higher gear ratios, it may raise the top speed past the maximum rating of other components. Any modification that makes the vehicle heavier may cause the brakes to be insufficient. Any modification that changes the weight distribution may have a number of difficult to predict consequences for steering and stopping. Tires that are better on a track may be worse in the rain. Tires with a different diameter may cause the speedometer to mislead the driver. Tuning the engine to reach higher RPMs may cause excessive hydraulic pressure and damages the brakes or steering. Anyone making any modification or repair may use non-OEM parts with arbitrarily different specifications. These are all complicated engineering decisions that depend on the assumptions made by the OEM. Maybe the brakes are sufficient with an extra 700 pounds, maybe not. Hardware isn't simpler than software, the assumptions are just less explicit. And encoding the complexity in software rather than hardware can make them less error-prone because software is more adaptable. It can read sensors and make realtime calculations. The assumptions encoded in hardware are static.
- adrianN 8y agoHardware is a lot simpler than software, because there are far fewer parts that can interact. Cars run millions of lines of code, they have far fewer mechanical components. There is a reason why software is eating the world, it's because you can have a lot more complexity for a lot less money.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago