6 ms·
Similarly to how agreed-upon overflights increase security (as your opponent knows you're not preparing an attack and/or are keeping to treaty obligations) one
by gumby 8y ago
Similarly to how agreed-upon overflights increase security (as your opponent knows you're not preparing an attack and/or are keeping to treaty obligations) one could consider this a good thing.
Of course China is not currently a military threat to the US, at least at the level deserving attention of a US president (e.g. random encounters in the Spratleys are jostling, not escalation).
I certainly don't think this is a responsible practice but it's interesting to consider it in a game theoretic context.
- smt88 8y agoChina isn't a military threat, but Russia has proved that military power isn't necessary to sow chaos and destabilize the US. You don't even need military-grade hackers.
- downandout 8y agoRussia has "destabilized" the US? That is hyperbole at best, unless you know something I don't. What exactly are you referring to? They seem to have destabilized the US media, in the sense that they can't publish enough stories about Russia. But have they actually achieved anything in any real way?
- jacobsheehy 8y agoRussia actively attacks US election infrastructure. This is not an unknown thing, it is well-documented over the last few years and is happening right now. Yes, Russia has "destabilized" the US. Our elections were hacked with both real physical hacks and lies-at-scale through sophisticated propaganda. People are dying in the streets from the actions taken by violent right-wing people who are directly encouraged by language from RT and from the President. This is not some fantasy of fear, this is the real deal. The US has a major political stability problem, where the party in power has made it clear they do not respect elections, will not respect the outcome if they lose, constantly gather support to jail people who have committed no crimes, etc. Yes, Russia, through its hacking, violence, and other election fuckery, has destabilized the US. If you "don't know" this stuff, then you haven't been paying attention for the last few years. None of this is a disputable conspiracy, it's just facts. Sad facts. :(
- downandout 8y agoThere are so many issues with your comment that I don't know where to begin, but I won't bother addressing all of them because it will just devolve into typical Hn-ness. I will address the more egregious misstatements you have made. Russia actively attacks US election infrastructure Running a few ads, with a small budget, or having some fake Twitter accounts post things that millions of others are already saying, in my view does not constitute an "attack on the US election infrastructure". Our elections were hacked with...real physical hacks That would be news indeed. Source? People are dying in the streets from the actions taken by violent right-wing people who are directly encouraged by language from RT and from the President Source? constantly gather support to jail people who have committed no crimes Source? Please name one person currently in jail in the US that has not been convicted of a crime and does not have a criminal case pending. Again, that would indeed be news.
- jacobsheehy 8y ago> There are so many issues with your comment that I don't know where to begin, but I won't bother addressing all of them because it will just devolve into typical Hn-ness. But I will address the more egregious misstatements you have made. There's no need to insult me to start with. Please abide by the HN guidelines and do not just start insulting people. Let's just talk about all this and get right to the content: > Running a few ads, with a small budget, or having some fake Twitter accounts post things that millions of others are already saying, in my view does not constitute an "attack on the US election infrastructure". I don't know what you're talking about. I'm talking about specifically hacking the voting infrastructure and removing voters from the voting rolls. You're going on about ads or something with a small budget (???) but I have no idea what you're talking about. Here is a citation that Russia directly hacks the elections themselves: https://slate.com/technology/2018/07/russia-election-hacking-muellers-latest-indictment-suggests-it-could-be-even-more-damaging-next-time.html https://slate.com/technology/2018/07/russia-election-hacking... > That would be news indeed. Source? Oh yeah, that is the biggest news of the last two years. I picked a source and cited it. > Source? Well, Heather Heyer was murdered in this fashion. > constantly gather support to jail people who have committed no crimes Well Beto for one! Ted Cruz trying to drum up support to jail Beto O'Rourke last night was wild. Scary and sad :(
- fit2rule 8y agoThe problem is that American interests have extended beyond the limits of the American borders for too long - China exercising its rights to protect its own interests outside its borders is a response to that, which automatically triggers American hubris: "nobody, but the 'greatest nation on Earth', should have the right to say its interests extend beyond its borders" .. this is the point of American hegemony in the world. If America doesn't do it, someone else will - so eventually, America becomes the very threat it was resisting all along: a totalitarian state which uses its military might to usurp the interests of other nations, at any and all cost.
- komali2 8y agoIn surprised to hear someone say China is not a military threat to the United States. Can you expound on this? For example, I believe China could easily organize and fund far more terrorist attacks than, say, bin laden ever did. Furthermore, their terrorist attacks could much more easily utilize nuclear material.
- snowwrestler 8y agoChina has no interest in funding terrorist attacks against the U.S. or anyone else. They want to be a Great Power, not a rogue state. Aside from nukes, which would draw an obvious and unstoppable reprisal from the U.S., China does not have the military capability to meaningfully threaten the U.S. They don't have the aircraft, ships, subs, landing craft, etc. And again, I don't know why they would want that. They do have the means to threaten their regional neighbors, though, and some of them are U.S. allies. That's the WWIII threat: that Chinese regional aggression sucks the U.S. into a military confrontation on China's turf.
- komali2 8y agoInteresting. I feel I could say the same of the USA vs China - any outright attack against China would draw a massive response, and I hardly believe the USA is capable of occupying China in any meaningful way.
- gumby 8y agoWell, I'm not sure what you mean by "massive response" as China's nuclear capability is more for regional prurposes (i.e. India) though I do believe they have some ICBMs capable of reaching anywhere in north america. But their military resources are much smaller (e.g. they only have a couple of aircraft carriers and no supercarriers) and the PLA isn't really set up for projection of force at a distance. I do agree to the extent that though the US would win any initial skirmish the long term viability of such an effort close to or on the Chinese mainland is probably not great. Then again I can't come up with any reason the US would want to fight a war with China either (or vice versa), but who knows these days.
- jacobsheehy 8y agoA physically violent and currently-attacking-us Russia, spying on the communications of the US President*, is _not_ a good thing. This is a very clear military threat.
- sandworm101 8y agoOverflights check on what countries are physically doing. Stepping up that concept, trust but verify, to include policy changes is a big leap. Overflights do not provide a chance to directly alter behavior in the way that diagramming a president's cellpohone patterns can. This isn't verification. This is intelligence being used to alter policy. That isn't trust but verify, that's, examine, meddle and influence.
- _iyig 8y ago>Of course China is not currently a military threat to the US ... I would disagree. China routinely threatens U.S. naval vessels which transit disputed regions of the South China Sea, and maintains a large battery of missiles pointed at Taiwan, an American diplomatic ally. They have also developed hypersonic anti-carrier missiles, and are rapidly expanding their blue-water navy.
- gumby 8y agoI referred the jostling in the Spratleys in my comment and on their ability to project force in another comment down thread. They are rapidly expanding a blue water navy from a tiny starting point (e.g. recently bringing online a Ukranian aircraft carrier (not a super carrier) doubled their carrier force) and have a few remote naval bases, but their strength, to the degree it exists, is locally strong and externally mainly soft power. There is no question the US would abandon Taiwan the same as Macarthur pulled back to the southern half of Australia in WWII. Pragmatics argues this -- as pragmatics argue against China actually attacking Taiwan militarily any time in the next 30 years. E.g. bombing Hon Hai would degrade Chinese manufacturing unacceptably.