3 ms·
> Preserving the building did not, the majority said, constitute a “taking” of the property, depriving the owners of the opportunity to build to such an extent
by dsfyu404ed 8y ago
> Preserving the building did not, the majority said, constitute a “taking” of the property, depriving the owners of the opportunity to build to such an extent that they should be compensated.
In the long term I see that being regarded among other high quality landmark rulings such as Wickard v. Filburn (that's sarcasm btw). There is already a means for the government to acquire control over private property, eminent domain and it involves compensation. Giving the government a magic wand they can wave at no cost to tell people what to do on their property is not appropriate.
- andrewla 8y agoAdd to that Kelo v. City of New London, which allowed the taking of private property to give to another private party. As an odd bit of trivia, the dissent to Penn Central Transportation Co. v. New York City was authored by then-associate Justice Rehnquist and joined by J.P. Stevens. The opinion of the court in Kelo was delivered by Stevens, and Rehnquist, as chief justice, joined in the dissent. Rehnquist stood fast on preventing the restriction of the takings clause, while Stevens relaxed his stance.
- cryptonector 8y agoAnother solution was to call it a taking (which it was) and allow it after the city paid the property owners (which the city could have done). Basically, what the Court did was signal to developers that they must never build anything pretty or legendary that 50 years later might get termed a landmark. And I say this even though I'm ecstatic that Grand Central Terminal was saved, and very sad that Penn Station was not. These two opinions can co-exist. IMO the city should just have paid for the taking, or found some other way to compensate the owners. And the Court should have said so.
- gamblor956 8y agoFrom the opinion: "The trial court's grant of relief was reversed on appeal, the New York Court of Appeals ultimately concluding that there was no "taking," since the Landmarks Law had not transferred control of the property to the city, but only restricted appellants' exploitation of it." The plaintiffs wanted to tear down the building. They weren't allowed to. They were otherwise allowed to do whatever they wanted with the building as long as its visual features remained intact. This is not a taking. And it turns out that requiring them to maintain the station was the right decision in the long run--the station is now far more profitable than it would have been as just another crappy NYC office tower. Note also that Wickard v. Filburn reached the appropriate conclusion. In that case, a man grew wheat for sale and sold at least part of his production to out-of-state buyers. He grew more of it than allowed due to war-time restrictions, and used the excess to feed his own livestock. The court ruled that this violated the law. And that was completely correct. If he hadn't grown any excess, he would have needed to feed his livestock out of his permitted stock of grain, and would have had less to sell (if any) to others. Thus, a direct effect on interstate commerce.