3 ms·
Shakespeare, who invented half of modern English vocabulary, used singular they. You're anecdotal experience of getting called out as incorrect does not confli
by joshuamorton 8y ago
Shakespeare, who invented half of modern English vocabulary, used singular they.
You're anecdotal experience of getting called out as incorrect does not conflict with GPs statement that such things are and were rare.
- jki275 8y agoI'll argue your grasp of grammatical English is poor based the errors in your comment, but "Shakespeare did it" doesn't change the rules. Shakespeare did a lot of things that aren't accepted in English grammar today. My anecdote is simply based on accepted and correct grammar. You won't find it any different in any academic setting or any other setting where grammar is important.
- joshuamorton 8y agoOr perhaps I'm posting from a phone which is prone to changing my words on occasion. Please remember to abide by the hn guidelines. And no, your belief is based on what you learned is correct grammar. Authors and scholars have disagreed about singular they since the time of Shakespeare and English, having no central authority, has allowed singular they since the middle ages. Singular they was only "outlawed" in the 1800s, with the reasoning was that he could stand in for they in all cases, because one should never mix a plural pronoun with a singular antecedent. This forgot that "you" is also plural, or at least was originally. The OED and Merriam-Webster both recognize singular they, as do the Chicago manual of style, the wapo style guide, and the associated press stylebook. It is accepted and correct grammar.
- jki275 8y agoCorrect grammar is important in a discussion of grammar, is it not? They don't "recognize" it any more than anyone else, in recognizing that people use it. It's still grammatically incorrect. My "belief" isn't so much based on what I learned but on how the language has been used. I'm not a student of grammar, I'm a computer scientist. Yes, there is no "central authority", but then you appeal to authority throughout the rest of your comment. Stallman really does cover that well in his essay: "Every language has grammar rules. They are in the minds of speakers of the language — including, for English, me. The fact that they weren't decided by an official edict doesn't mean these rules are a trivial matter; demanding people change their grammar rules is an affront. You might succeed in convincing me to change the English grammar rules in my mind, but don't you dare demand it".
- joshuamorton 8y agoYou make a bunch of unjustified statements, so I'd ask that you justify them before we continue. But I'll also clarify things. >Correct grammar is important in a discussion of grammar, is it not? Justify this. > It's still grammatically incorrect. Justify this. You make this claim, but you haven't ever justified it. At this point this conversation has become "Singular they has been used historically, is currently used now, and while previously controversial, is now considered by many to be correct". Your response to this is has repeatedly been "ok but its still wrong". And given that common usage and available experts both contract that statement, I'm unclear on what you're basing this opinion on. >My "belief" isn't so much based on what I learned but on how the language has been used. And your belief here is wrong based on how language has been used and is being used, which is what I've been saying. If you're belief that something is bad grammar is based on whether or not it is in common usage, then showing that it is in common usage and has been used should be enough to demonstrate that perhaps you were incorrect, and that it really is correct. But for some reason this isn't enough, and you've been very coy when explaining why you disagree. Hence my request to justify the claim that singular they is incorrect grammar. >Yes, there is no "central authority", but then you appeal to authority throughout the rest of your comment. No, I justify the claim that use of the singular they is widely accepted in academic and "serious" grammatical settings, indirect contradiction to your claim that > You won't find it any different in any academic setting or any other setting where grammar is important. As for Stallman's comments, I'm not telling you to use singular they. He is, or at least he is if you use the GNU mailing lists. What I am telling you is that your reasoning for believing that singular they is wrong is not well reasoned, and you've repeatedly not addressed that central point, instead choosing to focus on a typo.
- jki275 8y agoI think you've misunderstood Stallman's comments, if you've read them. I'll reproduce them here again as I've done other places, though generally I wouldn't cut and paste several times into one thread: " Every language has grammar rules. They are in the minds of speakers of the language — including, for English, me. The fact that they weren't decided by an official edict doesn't mean these rules are a trivial matter; demanding people change their grammar rules is an affront. You might succeed in convincing me to change the English grammar rules in my mind, but don't you dare demand it. " I don't have to justify myself to you, the statements I made are axioms. The language form you want to be correct is in fact not "in common use", it's simply a bit more commonly used in that fashion [I]inside certain cultural circles[/I]. If that's where you run, you perhaps wouldn't know that outside those circles in the vast majority of spoken and especially written English it is still considered incorrect. And I'm actually now curious if you know that you're != your, because you've done it again and autocorrect generally gets that right in my experience.