7 ms·
The myth of whiteness in classical sculpture
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> In the nineteen-thirties, restorers at the British Museum polished the Elgin marbles, the most treasured sculptures from the Acropolis, until they were as white and shiny as pearls. As good an argument as any for the Greeks getting them back from those ignorant barbarians.
- scoot_718 8y agoIf they weren't faded from their tacky paint jobs perhaps the classics would never have gained popularity.
- jmh530 8y agoThis has been known for some time...
- SiliconWallies 8y agoThe New Yorker really does have a hard on for attacking White people and western civilization. Next thing we'll be reading that crap again about Africans being the kings of Egypt. I'll be happy when this hard on for POC is over and the NPCs move onto the next minority to defend. Pedophiles seem to be trending.
- montenegrohugo 8y agoI'd love to see the pyramids when they were first built. They are still very impressive 4000 years later, but to see them when just completed, with the golden top and the polished limestone and all the other decoration that probably existed then... The massive structures still remain, but they must be ruins compared to their past splendor.
- KineticLensman 8y agoDitto Hadrian's Wall [0] in the UK. It's still impressive as it cuts across the Northern moors, but is a mass of grey stone. Back in the day, it was believed to have been plastered and whitewashed, creating a stunning 70 mile long visual marker of the Northern extent of the Roman empire [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hadrian%27s_Wall https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hadrian%27s_Wall
- okyougotmenow 8y agowe wuz sculpted n shit, these beautiful works of art that demonstrated sculpting skill that is impressive to this day were actually tacky garbage because we hired self-hating retards to paint over them with crayola to own the whites > By Margaret Talbot > Her brothers are both journalists. Stephen Talbot is a long-time documentary producer for public television (Frontline, Sound Tracks: Music Without Borders) and David Talbot is the founder of Salon.com oy vey what a coincidence > edit: already flagged post-2016 HN is absolutely pathetic. I can sense Sam Altman's tongue drooling on Hillary's necrotic #&*!$^ as I speak.
- topang1 8y agoQuite a bias article with a political axe to grind starting straight away with the title. I thought hyper-political articles weren't allowed here?
- mo1ok 8y agoYeah this doesn’t belong on hacker news...
- baldfat 8y ago> political axe to grind starting straight away with the title Yes someone absolutely didn't read the article nor look at the examples of the paint remains found on the statues. > Incredibly bias article The reason the whole idea of color and whiteness was presented was to answer the question of why did people remove the color from the objects and why wasn't it common knowledge about how they were actually painted objects. Political against Alt-Right? I have a political ax to grind against Alt-Right and so should you.
- topang1 8y agoAre you trying to say a title including "The myth of whiteness" isn't trying to allude to something else? Injecting American ID pol onto non-Amercian cultures is incredibly toxic and colonial. > The reason the whole idea of color and whiteness was presented was to answer the question of why did people remove the color from the objects and why wasn't it common knowledge about how they were actually painted objects. This has been common knowledge for a long time - this article isn't really about that once you actually read through it. > Political against Alt-Right Facts have nothing to do with the Alt-Right they don't tend to like them, however using other people's history to take a shot at different political groups is gross it doesn't matter what side you're on.
- Chazprime 8y agoI think perhaps you’ve been reading too much Breitbart?
- chongli 8y agoThis is a textbook example of the trope reality is unrealistic [1]. Those sculptures look kitschy and childish when painted. Seeing them that way destroys my childhood image of the ancient Greeks. It's so strange! It fits right in with my struggle to imagine the 19th century and early 20th century as being anything other than black and white, since almost (exceptions exist [2]) all of the photos from back then were monochrome. [1] https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/RealityIsUnrealistic https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/RealityIsUnreali... [2] https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Alim_Khan_(1880%E2%80%931944),_Emir_of_Bukhara,_photographed_by_S.M._Prokudin-Gorskiy_in_1911.jpg https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Alim_Khan_(1880%E2%8...
- johnchristopher 8y agoWouldn't exposure to Western movies, comics or cartoons set in that period lessen that impact ?
- iguy 8y agoIn addition, it's also hard to imagine how they looked to people then. By which I mean that people would not have seen so much other color in their everyday lives -- obviously trees & flowers were as now, but paint and dyes were expensive and nowhere near as bright & varied as today.
- maxxxxx 8y agoIt would probably have had the same effect as cool computer animations have on us now "wow that's cool!"
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- michaelt 8y agoThose sculptures look kitschy and childish when painted. Perhaps that's partly because painting techniques have advanced a lot since the ancient Greeks, while realistic figure sculpting hasn't changed that much? I assume they went for that style of painting because it was historically authentic? Presumably they don't want to decorate a 50 BC statue with 1750 AD painting techniques.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- okyougotmenow 8y agoTHE MYTH OF WHITENESS
- brazzy 8y agoAnd look at all the triggered racists creeping out of the woodwork in the comments here...
- andrewl 8y agoFor more examples of what this might have looked like, see the Philadelphia Museum of Art, where the statues on the pediment are painted in the old style: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Pediment,_Philly_Art_Museum_%281%29.jpg https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Pediment,_Philly_Art... https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Pediment,_Philly_Art_Museum_%282%29.jpg https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Pediment,_Philly_Art...
- alricb 8y agoAnother thing that was "whitened", or rather, polished: medieval armor. A lot of it was painted, but the paint was removed by collectors and "conservators" in the 19th and 20th century.
- iguy 8y agoBuildings too: I think most gothic cathedrals were brightly painted inside, but now we know them in bare stone.
- Footkerchief 8y agoSource please! I'd like to read more.
- alricb 8y agoI don't have a book reference, but this talk by Tobias Capwell is my source: https://youtu.be/COAIQPsgZWY?t=2311 https://youtu.be/COAIQPsgZWY?t=2311
- SolaceQuantum 8y ago"As the artist and critic David Batchelor writes in his 2000 book, “Chromophobia,” at a certain point ignorance becomes willful denial—a kind of “negative hallucination” in which we refuse to see what is before our eyes. " It's interesting to note that this psychological phenomenon has occurred much before the prevalence of social media, and hasn't changed in how significant the cultural influence is of the phenomenon. I'm pretty interested if there's any solution at all to it.
- fedups 8y agoProfessor Bond and this finding are discussed as a case study of 'polarization cycles,' where innocuous claims somehow give rise to controversy in the book "Coddling of the American Mind." (this is obliquely referenced around the middle of the OP). For those interested in these online social dynamics I'd highly recommend the book.
- danans 8y agoThe Enlightenment, among many other things, was characterized by a movement toward simpler styles of attire, especially among men of higher means - i.e. no more high heels worn by men. That sort of dress became seen as superfluous. It was also the beginning of the modern sciences using rational methods, including the modern study of ancient art and archaeology. It wouldn't surprise me, therefore, if Enlightenment scholars and those who followed interpreted ancient aesthetics through their more recently acquired sense of style, or really projected their style on the ancients, since it would have flattered them to think that they shared a style sensibility with the ancients. As a contrast, in India, where the Enlightenment arrived relatively late, the color intensity of ancient aesthetics has been preserved to a far greater degree.