4 ms·
Hi Apple. Please: • add VPN on/off to control center • allow per-app VPN via Apple Configurator, without enterprise MDM • once the above two are available,
by walterbell 8y ago
Hi Apple. Please:
• add VPN on/off to control center
• allow per-app VPN via Apple Configurator, without enterprise MDM
• once the above two are available, we can use Tor, IDS, DPI or pihole on a per-application basis, to reduce data harvesting
• bonus1: allow the open-source iOS MDM community OR the iOS Shortcuts community to make it easy for novice users to have one-click install of "privacy-plus configurations"
• bonus2: provide open-source code for on-device, silicon-enabled voice recognition using Neural Engine. In the meantime, allow anonymous (no iCloud login) use of Siri via Tor on a per-application basis
- mtgx 8y agoIt would help if they decoupled the so-called "end-to-end encrypted" iMessage from automatic backups to centralized iCloud servers to which all governments have access.
- saagarjha 8y agoiMessage backups are not “automatic”. You must opt-in before they leave your device.
- blattimwind 8y ago• location data toggle in control center
- tananaev 8y agoThis is my most desired feature in iPhone. Disabling location service, when you don't need it, helps with both battery consumption and privacy. I don't understand why Apple doesn't want to implement an easy switch option, unless they want to track your location for some reason.
- macintux 8y agoI would wager they think it's confusing and possibly dangerous. How many people would leave it on as they drive away from home, and then struggle with their phones as they're driving? Apple doesn't generally expose more options than it thinks a substantial number of people need. That's a UX decision, not a "Apple wants to track you forever" evil business decision. I'll admit I wouldn't mind an option like this, but I'm fine with three levels of location service controls for apps.
- tananaev 8y agoThere are ways to make it user friendly. iOS can provide some kind of API that apps can use to explicitly request user to switch location services on. Just like permissions. They can also have an option is settings to ONLY allow foreground app to use location service. I bet most people don't want random apps to know their location in the background. They only want location when they know what it's used for (e.g. Google Maps, Uber/Lyft etc). If Apple is really so pro-privacy, they can find a way to stop apps tracking location in the background.
- Tehnix 8y agoFor the second point: Settings -> Privacy -> Location Services and then set the app to “While using the app”.
- macintux 8y agoThat's not quite the same thing, because with that setting apps can run in the background and continue to track your location. Usually you want this (e.g., Waze), but not always (e.g., Uber).
- Tehnix 8y agoNo. That would quite literally be the “Always” setting... For example, for Messenger to share live location, it needs location sharing to be always, and not just “While using”. With while using though, you are still able to share a pin point of you current location.
- jbrooksuk 8y ago> add VPN on/off to control center I really hoped they'd add this in iOS12.
- walterbell 8y ago<deleted, replied to wrong comment>
- saagarjha 8y ago…did you just reply to your own comment?
- walterbell 8y agoNot sure what happened there, was trying to reply to @mtgx https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18291227 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18291227
- geezerjay 8y agoYou're addressing the technical problem but Tim Cook is addressing the political problem, which is more effective at tackling the root causes.
- ganzuul 8y agoDubious proposition. Many programmers work to solve political problems through technological means. TOR is an example of this.
- bryanrasmussen 8y agoAnd is Tor an example of a solution to the problem that has become widely adopted in society causing the problem to go away? Because if not then maybe a political solution to the problem is in order.
- ganzuul 8y agoAnother example is encryption in general. Once export restricted in the U.S. as munitions, the rest of the internet simply routed around that censorship.
- geezerjay 8y ago> Many programmers work to solve political problems through technological means. The real-world effectiveness of any technical solution depends on the political will to enforce it. Without no political will, technical solutions are not effective or enforceable, or even deployable. A political solution on the other hands eliminates the need to even consider a tech solution.
- booleandilemma 8y agoYou can’t solve a political problem through technological means, you can only provide workarounds. Geeky, awkward workarounds. TOR is an example of this.
- kkarakk 8y ago
- rubyfan 8y agoI’d like to see better sand boxing of the Photo album on iOS. Facebook, LinkedIn and others are known to raid your photos if they have access to it. Ideally you could limit their ability to read and write to just a specific photo album. Or limit write and read separately. At the moment your ability to enable and disable the permission is based on what permission the app requests and they show up together.
- saagarjha 8y agoiOS has long had an API for allowing access to individual photos from the system photo picker. Unfortunately many apps eschew this because they prefer having access to all of the user’s photos.
- bloak 8y agoThat shouldn't matter. The OS should let you create a fake photo collection which gets shown instead of the real one to apps you don't trust. This idea is obvious and very old. At least in the case of Android contact lists people have been asking for this for as long as I can remember. Why has it still not been implemented on iOS at least? Or has it now been implemented? I've been avoiding both Android and iOS because of stuff like this. Does anyone want to sell me a phone that runs Debian with the option of running Android or iOS in a VM with appropriate management functions that would make it very hard for an app to misbehave?
- acqq 8y ago> The OS should let you create a fake photo collection which gets shown instead of the real one to apps you don't trust. Many times yes. And even more important, the contacts! Now it's you have to "give the app all the contacts" even if you know you want to give it only one or two. And of those one or two, just the number. Not the picture, not the date of birth, not the address. In short we should be able to pre-select what any app actually sees of of all the databases, records and fields. It sounds too technical but it could be done properly.
- how_to_bake 8y agoI believe you now can use a Siri shortcut to create a button that goes in your widgets area that turns the VPN on or off.
- walterbell 8y agoThanks for the tip. So arbitrary buttons can be placed in widget area?
- how_to_bake 8y agoYes, I think. Check this out https://www.reddit.com/r/ios/comments/9gocy9/we_can_finally_turn_off_wifi_on_ios_with_one/ https://www.reddit.com/r/ios/comments/9gocy9/we_can_finally_...