3 ms·
What do you suggest Apple should do instead of comply with the law? Require it's employees to incriminate themselves? I'm not the GP but I've seen this exact f
by chongli 8y ago
What do you suggest Apple should do instead of comply with the law? Require it's employees to incriminate themselves?
I'm not the GP but I've seen this exact form of complaint many times. I think the usual response is "stop doing business in China." I don't know how that's supposed to work, though, since Chinese companies make all of Apple's hardware.
- thecatspaw 8y agoI guess it would extend into "dont buy chinese hardware"
- pcnix 8y agoThen you'd have a competitor stepping in that bought Chinese hardware. A company's ethics stretch only as far as it's survival is guaranteed. Corporations are black boxes that optimise for profit, not ethics or integrity.
- pluma 8y agoHow does sourcing in China require you to sell to the Chinese market? I don't see how Apple could be compelled to open their iCloud to the Chinese government if they're not operating iCloud in China and don't directly have Chinese customers.
- simonh 8y agoChina requires that the services be operated from within China and requires government access to the data centres. I suspect this is one of the driving forces behind Apples efforts to do as much AI Balts is on the device, and employ encryption and advanced anonymising methods on data that is transmitted to the back end.
- pluma 8y agoYes, as I said, sourcing from China doesn't mean you have to sell your products in the Chinese market. If the only way to be an iCloud user in China is to trick Apple into thinking you're not in China, Apple can't recognise Chinese users and thus can't help the government spy on them. Apple presumably doesn't provide iCloud in markets that the US has a trade embargo against, so why wouldn't they voluntarily abstain from providing it in China where it's not possible to provide the service without co-operating with the Chinese government to subvert their users' privacy. I'm not saying that Apple should do this. I'm saying that it's dishonest to claim Apple's hands are tied. Unless the Chinese government is using the supply chain as leverage to force Apple to provide it access regardless of whether or not Apple intends to provide services in China, whether Apple is using China as supplier or not is irrelevant.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoAre values not backed by a willingness to make sacrifices worth anything?
- chongli 8y agoSacrifices for what, though? Let's say Apple does take a stand against China's human rights record. Then what? Apple pulls out of the country and a Chinese company fills the void in the market, possibly handing over even more user data to the government. What has been accomplished by Apple's "sacrifice"?
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoApple customers elsewhere in the world are assured of Apple's integrity in this regard. Of course, it is a bit unreasonable to expect Apple to actually do that, but it is also a bit unreasonable to believe that Apple will guard your privacy anywhere else when push comes to shove.
- chongli 8y agoApple is not a human being, it is a company. That means expecting it to have integrity the way you would a person will only lead to disappointment. A better way to understand the actions of a company is to look at incentives. Apple does not have a huge incentive to collect and monetize user data the way Google and Facebook do. Therefore, Apple has an incentive to try to differentiate their product based on this fact. That's all that is going on here, morality does not enter into the picture.
- umanwizard 8y agoChinese companies assemble Apple’s hardware. The phase of iPhone manufacture that’s done in China involves screwdrivers and glue, not high-tech fabs. It could be done elsewhere for a smaller price increase than you might expect.
- fhood 8y agoI read somewhere that the issue is (for almost all electronics manufacturers) that all of those hi-tech fabs are also physically located in China, so you save a great deal of money and time.