5 ms·
Is that the same type of moral speech as he did when he said "Privacy is fundamental human right" and then gave keys to iCloud to Chinese government some time l
by izacus 8y ago
Is that the same type of moral speech as he did when he said "Privacy is fundamental human right" and then gave keys to iCloud to Chinese government some time later?
He's a CEO of a multi-billion publicly traded corporation. Content warning applies for everything he (or any such CEO/PR service) says.
- simonh 8y agoApple's stance has been completely consistent. They comply with the law while making their ethical beliefs and stance as a company clear where they disagree with it. What do you suggest Apple should do instead of comply with the law? Require it's employees to incriminate themselves?
- skc 8y agoIs this really true though? Has Tim Cook ever criticized the Chinese government or does he only ever speak on these issues when it comes to the US?
- enitihas 8y agoNope, he does the opposite. Here is his own words from a Chinese conference. “The theme of this conference -- developing a digital economy for openness and shared benefits -- is a vision we at Apple share,” Cook said. “We are proud to have worked alongside many of our partners in China to help build a community that will join a common future in cyberspace." Source: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-12-04/cook-kisses-the-ring https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-12-04/cook-kiss...
- chongli 8y agoWhat do you suggest Apple should do instead of comply with the law? Require it's employees to incriminate themselves? I'm not the GP but I've seen this exact form of complaint many times. I think the usual response is "stop doing business in China." I don't know how that's supposed to work, though, since Chinese companies make all of Apple's hardware.
- thecatspaw 8y agoI guess it would extend into "dont buy chinese hardware"
- pcnix 8y agoThen you'd have a competitor stepping in that bought Chinese hardware. A company's ethics stretch only as far as it's survival is guaranteed. Corporations are black boxes that optimise for profit, not ethics or integrity.
- pluma 8y agoHow does sourcing in China require you to sell to the Chinese market? I don't see how Apple could be compelled to open their iCloud to the Chinese government if they're not operating iCloud in China and don't directly have Chinese customers.
- simonh 8y agoChina requires that the services be operated from within China and requires government access to the data centres. I suspect this is one of the driving forces behind Apples efforts to do as much AI Balts is on the device, and employ encryption and advanced anonymising methods on data that is transmitted to the back end.
- pluma 8y agoYes, as I said, sourcing from China doesn't mean you have to sell your products in the Chinese market. If the only way to be an iCloud user in China is to trick Apple into thinking you're not in China, Apple can't recognise Chinese users and thus can't help the government spy on them. Apple presumably doesn't provide iCloud in markets that the US has a trade embargo against, so why wouldn't they voluntarily abstain from providing it in China where it's not possible to provide the service without co-operating with the Chinese government to subvert their users' privacy. I'm not saying that Apple should do this. I'm saying that it's dishonest to claim Apple's hands are tied. Unless the Chinese government is using the supply chain as leverage to force Apple to provide it access regardless of whether or not Apple intends to provide services in China, whether Apple is using China as supplier or not is irrelevant.
- LunaSea 8y agoOr not deal with countries that don't match their ethical beliefs. You know, actually taking a stand instead of empty words.
- Cthulhu_ 8y agoThat rules out the US as well you know.
- theshrike79 8y agoChina is the only country that can produce modern electronics at global scales. If you piss them off, your company will be bankrupt in weeks.
- OskarS 8y agoI agree, and you can also tell that Apple is on the right side of this because of that FBI phone unlocking case. Apple fought the government tooth and nail, and they made it literally impossible to do for later models of phones. That whole incident really impressed me. Of the "giant evil megacorporations that will dominate our cyberpunk future", I think Apple has slightly more moral sense and backbone compared to Google and Facebook. Not much, but it's something.
- izacus 8y agoThat's an interesting view, considering all the outrage on this site related to Google potentially entering the Chinese market under their law. It was deemed utterly immoral... and Apple gets a free pass although their own CEO it talking about human rights?
- OskarS 8y agoI mean, it's just my view, I don't speak for anyone else, much less "this site". I personally don't think it's realistic to require these companies to totally stay out of the Chinese market, that's just not going to happen.
- emsy 8y agoYou are either utterly uniformed or intentionally misleading. Apple located the data center in China, as Chinese law requires while maintaining the same encryption standards they have for all of their customers. Google was collaborating with China in creating a censorial search engine behind the great firewall. Completely different things.
- Aunche 8y agoHow is that any different? Google isn't doing anything different from any other search engine in China. Of course, they're collaborating with China, just like Apple in order to build a data center there.
- 8y ago