5 ms·
Aside from the other (excellent) comments already made, Apple neither has the same market share as Android nor does it have a (near) monopoly in search or adver
by Fnoord 8y ago
Aside from the other (excellent) comments already made, Apple neither has the same market share as Android nor does it have a (near) monopoly in search or advertising.
- sysstemlord 8y agoThis excuse is always mentioned whenever such comparison appears. But it doesn't convince me. Having a smaller market share doesn't mean you can get away with breaking the law.
- Fnoord 8y agoIt isn't a get out of jail for free card. Laws still apply for any company however for a (convicted) monopolist different laws apply than for a random (successful) company. Microsoft and Google are convicted monopolists.
- raverbashing 8y agoExcept the law does apply differently if you have the majority of the market share.
- robocat 8y agoThere are countries where Apple has a dominant market share (e.g. Japan). You might argue Google is dominant in advertising worldwide, but Facebook is a contender in many countries (e.g. in the Philippines, Facebook is "the internet" as an approximation). If you want to pick and choose subsectors, I am sure we could pick markets where mobile is one of the words and the second word is also something Apple absolutely dominates. The world is a big place to make sweeping generalisations about. Edit: parent article is about Portugal, not the world. A friend said to me: working in antitrust, on either side, a key is defining the market.
- arendtio 8y agoWell, while the market share is an important side note, the point is that they are a platform provider too. Microsoft had the problem a few years ago with bundling their Internet Explorer on Windows (and making it hard for the competition to have a chance). For Apple, the situation is a bit easier, as they don't allow any third party app stores at all, so any competition would probably encourage their users to break Apples 'Terms of Use', which in turn would make a lawsuit even more difficult. In my opinion, platform providers should be obliged to open their platform for all kinds of third-party services & tools but I am sure, Apple/Google/Microsoft/etc. will find other ways to discriminate others on their platform and push their services.
- candiodari 8y agoExactly, the law should be modified to force platform providers to guarantee their users: 1) the ability to install their own apps, no restrictions (IF approved by owner) 2) the ability to get apps from wherever they want I would be much happier.
- joelhaasnoot 8y agoNote that Apple still has a 35% market share where I live and I'm sure that's mostly factoring in new sales. Apples's devices have big refurbished appeal. The market share is not insignificant.