2 ms·
I've written about this topic myself, though the piece I have in mind is probably not online anymore. No one particularly cares what I think because I'm not fam
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
I've written about this topic myself, though the piece I have in mind is probably not online anymore. No one particularly cares what I think because I'm not famous.
I find myself wondering exactly why we should particularly care what Stallman thinks. Because he's famous? I see no reason to think that the area of expertise that makes him famous somehow qualifies him to decide what's best here.
Granted, to some degree, it's framed as "This is what I do." But he knows many people will read it and take it seriously simply because he's famous.
Anyway, I have found myself tending towards using fewer pronouns and, as above, more frequently reiterating the name or descriptor of the person in question. I also tend towards use of singular they and rewriting sentences to sidestep such issues. It's hard at first, but, like any habit, gets easier over time.
An example is to say "whether you are a manor not" rather than to say "whether you are a man or a woman." The second phrase not only that excludes non-binary individuals etc, it is also agist: It excludes boys. The first phrase elegantly sidesteps all those issues.
It's often a case of less is more. Trying to actively be inclusive is typically a worse solution than trying to avoid being exclusive. Just don't implicitly exclude various categories rather than trying to figure out all the things you ought to include.
- belorn 8y agoI am not sure how often a person blog posts are posted on HN but I find it fairly common. HN do not follow the same rules as Wikipedia when it comes to judge whose opinion is worthy to be considered, neither requiring expert recognizing in the topic or third-party sources. It simply a question if enough people find the topic interesting within the time frame that a article has to be pushed to the front page. On the topic itself, I find from experience that people tend to default a pronoun as to themselves when they don't know the gender of a person and there is no other social clues. I prefer to not attribute malice to that which has a equal likely natural reason, and defaulting to oneself is a rather good explanation for why groups with mostly single-gender tend to use a pronounce of that gender. For that I agree that fewer pronouns, "they", and "person" is more clearer and honest than defaulting when one do not know the gender.