5 ms·
There's a wide variety of positions between "open borders" and "forcibly take refugee children away from their families and put both in detention facilities".
by joshuamorton 8y ago
There's a wide variety of positions between "open borders" and "forcibly take refugee children away from their families and put both in detention facilities".
One can object to the latter without supporting the former.
- sheepmullet 8y agoIn theory - in practice though we have had decades of weak borders.
- joshuamorton 8y agoWeak borders are still not open borders, and I again ask that you not conflate the two.
- exabrial 8y agoPlease name a crime where you are allowed to take your children with you when you're arrested.
- joshuamorton 8y agoRequesting asylum is not a crime, so I'm confused by this request.
- exabrial 8y agoI think that's more than valid. Does doing so require always crossing border illegally? Also, what percentage of people are under a legitimate threat of their lives (or relatives)?
- joshuamorton 8y agoWhy are you focusing on people who entered the country illegally? The trump admin has separated families who crossed the border legally at ports of entry and then requested asylum[1]. [1]: https://www.aclu.org/blog/immigrants-rights/immigrants-rights-and-detention/fact-checking-family-separation https://www.aclu.org/blog/immigrants-rights/immigrants-right...
- nyolfen 8y agocrossing the border illegally is
- xnyan 8y agoPlease name a misdemeanor crime that results in loss of custody of your dependent children on the first offense.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- fzeroracer 8y agoI'm pretty sure we don't permanently separate families for doing things like petty theft. There's also the the 'Affluenza' case where a teenager killed four people and got off scott-free. Well, until he was found fleeing probation in a foreign country and was dragged back here. So I don't know: Do you think crossing the border is worse than murder?
- nilkn 8y agoThe affluenza comparison feels like a "whataboutism" to me. Virtually nobody holds that case up as an example of the system working in a healthy and desirable way.
- fzeroracer 8y agoNo. It's not. The comment I directly replied to was asking for a crime where you can take your children with you when you're arrested. We've already established the fact the system is massively stacked against minorities. Then we continue to use 'but it's a crime!' as justification for vile and malicious behavior to people that have committed something without an actual victim like smoking marijuana or crossing the border. And again, we do not permanently separate families in every single case where someone commits misdemeanor. So then why is it OK to permanently separate all immigrants who cross the border despite it being the same level of crime? Give me one reason outside of 'racism and xenophobia.'
- nilkn 8y agoI'm only commenting on your affluenza comparison specifically. Here's an example of why I think the comparison is meaningless. Grand theft can be charged as a misdemeanor with up to a two year jail sentence. But Brock Turner was sentenced to only six months of jail time for rape. Do you think grand theft is worse than rape? Of course not, but the problem here is the Brock Turner sentence, not the sentencing for grand theft. This question could only be posed because, by design, I selected a more serious crime (rape) for which there exists at least one case where an inappropriately lenient sentence was given out. You did the same. By design, you selected a more serious crime (murder) for which there exists at least one case where an inappropriately lenient sentence was given out. You then used this highly dysfunctional example to draw a comparison to the less serious crime. But the simplest response to your question comparing crossing the border and murder is simply that the affluenza sentencing was wrong.