4 ms·
> If you are bitten by a raccoon, you can’t really decide not to get the rabies vaccine. It’s literally a life-or-death situation. But the price is incredibly h
by airstrike 8y ago
> If you are bitten by a raccoon, you can’t really decide not to get the rabies vaccine. It’s literally a life-or-death situation. But the price is incredibly high.
This, to me, is a perfect example of why healthcare should be subsidized by the government (either directly or through a government-backed insurance plan that you receive as a fallback).
Health isn't a good or service you choose to purchase. Demand is perfectly inelastic and everyone is subject to emergencies no matter how healthy their habits are.
- robertAngst 8y agoThat sounds great, but our US government has failed us for 30 years on healthcare. Not sure why anyone thinks that tax dollars would make the problem better.
- dreamdu5t 8y agoNo. Politicians favoring policies that deliberately exclude the poor have failed us for 30 years. We have never been able to make extensive progress on healthcare because voters elect politicians that fight against government health insurance (even fighting against spending government money on insurance for the disabled and elderly). Free market ideologues have failed us, not the government. This is painfully obvious if you've ever been in another civilized country (Taiwan, Canada, UK, etc.).
- dreamdu5t 8y agoLet's see, Republicans are for denying healthcare to people who can't afford it (a free market). Democrats are for ensuring access to healthcare for everyone, including those who can't afford it (using taxes, so everyone who can pay pays and the rich cover the poor). It's pretty fucking cut and dry at this point. We can dispense with the philosophical grandstanding.
- astrodust 8y agoSomething like 40% of Americans already receive "government health care" in some form or other. Any government employees, military, police, teachers, fire fighters, and so on, receive health care. Anyone who qualifies for Medicare does. Just push that number to 100%.
- mikeash 8y agoBecause it works fine in other places. The US government isn’t uniquely incapable. We just have to stop electing people whose major goal is to make it fail.
- wahern 8y agoObamacare provides that, at least in states that have accepted Medicare expansion. The story in other states with state-sponsored high risk pools seems complicated and arguably doesn't meet your criteria.
- lotophage 8y agoI've moved to the US from Australia, and the medical system here is pretty terrifying. People are always discussing "how to fix the homeless situation" here in San Francisco, but as I wander the streets I can't help but wonder how many of these people were bankrupted by a medical emergency.
- outworlder 8y ago> This, to me, is a perfect example of why healthcare should be subsidized by the government (either directly or through a government-backed insurance plan that you receive as a fallback). Nah, this doesn't really work in the US. All it does is to funnel money into the coffers of the companies that are creating the problem in the first place. There has to be some more regulation – companies need to be forced to be more transparent in their pricing, as well as to limit the markup they can add so they can 'negotiate' down. And then, there has to be some competition, as in many places people have no alternatives. That competition could even be with the government itself, in the form of government-run clinics or hospitals. This works in Brazil – you don't have to carry any form of insurance whatsoever if you don't want to. For major issues, you are covered just fine – trauma surgeons in the public network are among the best (at least in big population centers), and are often the same doctors that practice in private hospitals. My mother also got top notch cancer treatment for free. The last one is more location-dependent though. Even as a foreigner, should you get in a car crash or something, you'll be patched up nicely and not pay anything. Now, if you got a non life-threatening issue, then it can be a problem, as even the big hospitals may lack resources for everybody, so your appointment may be scheduled far in the future. To counter that, you can choose (and most middle class people do) to carry private insurance and not burden the public network. Private insurance is then cheaper that it would otherwise be because there is an upper limit on how much they can charge you – go too high and many people will drop insurance and private insurers (plus hospitals and clinics) would lose customers. The government will also provide essential medication for free (diabetes, high blood pressure, etc). It doesn't matter how high your income is. It is really not supposed to be rocket science. If a third world 'developing' economy can do it, with a much lower economic output, then the US could do it too. But not if it's a <whatever>care program that's allowing companies to continue charging $100 for a band-aid.
- airstrike 8y ago> This works in Brazil – you don't have to carry any form of insurance whatsoever if you don't want to. For major issues, you are covered just fine – trauma surgeons in the public network are among the best (at least in big population centers), and are often the same doctors that practice in private hospitals. My mother also got top notch cancer treatment for free. The last one is more location-dependent though. As a Brazilian, this literally made me laugh out loud. Brazilian healthcare sucks balls. Even the US does a better job at it. I'll just post this one article¹ about the guy who went to the ER in Rio to have one leg amputated and the doctors amputated the wrong one... __________ 1. https://extra.globo.com/noticias/rio/paciente-foi-preparado-para-amputar-perna-esquerda-mas-ficou-sem-as-duas-10262610.html https://extra.globo.com/noticias/rio/paciente-foi-preparado-...
- stephen_g 8y agoHaving a public option is the best way I think. In Australia, there is a private system and private insurance is fairly common, but when you can get generally as high or higher quality treatment free of charge in the public system, it makes it a lot harder for the private hospitals to charge crazy prices. The only downside is that given underfunding there are waiting lists for a lot of ‘elective’ things so if you don’t have private insurance you might wait up to, say, a year for a hip replacement whereas you could get it done within a week or two privately. So I pay $1K a year for private insurance just in case. But in our large cities the hospitals and emergency departments are as good as you’ll find anywhere so I always go to a public hospital in an emergency. You can even use your private insurance there so the state system gets some benefit.