3 ms·
This kind of reporting kills people. I'm always amazed at how irresponsible US newspapers are around reporting suspected suicide.
by DanBC 8y ago
This kind of reporting kills people. I'm always amazed at how irresponsible US newspapers are around reporting suspected suicide.
- nwsm 8y agoWhat do you mean?
- delecti 8y agoWe've known for a while (at least decades) that publicizing suicides tends to lead to copycat suicides.
- kenneth 8y agoSo what? Suicide is a choice. A really bad one. The whole world shouldn't be expected to walk on eggshells to prevent some people from making a really stupid choice. And maybe, on the other hand, it will serve as a cautionary tale to people who might have embarked on a path that led this way. If it changes the saving habits of a handful of engineers early in their career, I'd say it was more than worth it even if it led to a copycat or two.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- DanBC 8y ago> Suicide is a choice. You don't appear to know anything about suicidality. Yet you've made a firm, judgemental statement about it. > If it changes the saving habits of a handful of engineers early in their career, You don't have to write about suicide to do that.
- MFLoon 8y agoI don't buy that. This is a "slice of life" (slice of death?) piece telling a unglamorous but probably quite demographically representative about an older American getting pushed to their limit by a confluence of social factors. It's not a sensationalizing piece about someone jumping in public or some other sort of "blaze of glory" style suicide. Nor is it a headline - its in the NY region section, which people outside the region don't receive in print and probably don't click into online.
- DanBC 8y ago> I don't buy that. We have a variety of research. We have testimony from survivors who tells us that they were influenced by reports that include details of method, location, speculated reasons why the person killed themself, or details of the affect on friends and relatives. We can see in the months and years after a particular story is released how that influences deaths by suicide. Asphyixiation with helium became a lot more common in the UK after Michael Portillo made a tv programme about painless ways of capital punishment. Death by overdosing increases after tv shows depict a character dying by that method. > It's not a sensationalizing piece It doesn't have to be.
- MFLoon 8y agoEven given the existence of research establishing statistically significant correlation, I don't buy that that means there should just be a blanket gag on writing about suicide in the news. Just because there's some second order effect of disseminating some information doesn't mean we ought to withhold that information. Maybe there are numerous positive second order effects as well, which just aren't as easily measured. Just because some people have a bad reaction to some information doesn't justify taking away everyone else's freedom to share or access said information.
- thaumasiotes 8y agoHow do you feel about reporting school shootings?
- DanBC 8y agoI have no opinion about the reporting of mass killings or about US gun control laws. I'm pleased the UK has the laws we do.
- thaumasiotes 8y agoWhat's different about reporting suicides?