4 ms·
But wait a minute... Everyone here on HN and the technology press tells me there is this Shortage of Engineers™, and that employers are struggling to find softw
by ryandrake 8y ago
But wait a minute... Everyone here on HN and the technology press tells me there is this Shortage of Engineers™, and that employers are struggling to find software developers! Yet we also throw them away after 40? Something doesn’t add up...
- existencebox 8y agoThere's a shortage of Lamborghinis that I can afford. (I couldn't bring up the courage to click reply with just a quippy one liner, so let me assure you that I do actually think this is the truth behind things; plain and simple expectation mismatch. Companies want the best skills at the lowest prices. Candidates want the best offer they think can manage. Incentives will always put these actors to opposite ends of the spectrum.) Edit: I would at least like to understand the downvotes, since I say the above _as an engineer_ who knows I'll run up against companies saying they have a shortage while I'm banging on the door. (In fact that has literally happened, rejection the same week as an article from a firm that posted a "shortage" article)
- mywittyname 8y agoWe pass on qualified candidates for pretty silly reasons. Our process is basically, any one person in the interview process can veto an application. The problem is, the interviewers all seem to evaluate people for their current role, rather than the position the candidate is applying for. For example, one candidate interviewed for an engineering position that involved a lot of writing SQL/data wrangling. He listed machine learning on his resume and got interviewed by one of our researchers who lives and breaths ML and was torn apart. I didn't care that he didn't know how to do ML, even it if was listed on his resume, I was confident the candidate could do the job I needed him to. The candidate got the veto. I'm sure other companies pull the same crap. Interviewing is just all-around awful.
- InitialLastName 8y agoI'm usually skeptical of somebody who puts something on their resume that they can't back up. If you've claimed to know something, you'd better have studied up enough to have a conversation about it. One way I like candidates to get around this issue is to separate skills into categories like (for example) "very familiar with", "comfortable with", and "experience with". It's refreshing to see honest evaluations of skill levels, rather than people who say they know C/C++ but aren't capable of coding up a basic class in C++.
- mywittyname 8y agoSo am I. It comes down to how much knowledge you expect someone to have with a skill before listing it on their resume. In this guy's case, he came right out and said that his experience was limited to an online course on the subject. I do think this is another topic that make interviewing difficult. For example, I know Javascript pretty well, I've worked with it for years. However, I haven't done modern front-end development with it in a long time, thus I don't know Vue/Angular/React or even Node. But I have created browser plugins in pure JS. Some people would argue that I shouldn't list Javascript as a skill because I don't know the popular core libraries it's used with, and other people would have no problem with listing it. The problem is interviewees have no idea what kind of person they are going to run into. I do appreciate when people rank their skills, but that also takes up pretty valuable real-estate on a resume. I personally leave them off of my "list" of skills, but call them out on projects I've worked on the past. For example, I don't list C as a skill, but I do mention working on embedded devices with C for previous jobs.
- rubicon33 8y agoThat "shortage of engineers" is a complete fabricated story, designed and perpetuated by big tech companies, with 1 goal: keep costs from skyrocketing. If there were truly a shortage you would be seeing a DRAMATIC rise in salaries, not the mediocre rise you're seeing over the last 5 years. The truth of the matter is there's an enormous influx of new developers stateside thanks to the media frenzy around developer shortages. The pinnacle of this hype even reached the White House, with Obama urging young people to enter the field. We have plenty of developers here, companies just don't want to pay them more. And if you can't find them here there is an even larger pool of developers available abroad. Companies have perpetuated this myth of "not enough developers" and the nation bought it hook line and sinker.
- ryandrake 8y agoSorry, guess my sarcasm wasn’t clear. I agree with everything you said, and was poking fun at those people who complain they just can’t seem to find developers anywhere.
- not_real_acct 8y agoWhen I was 40, I'd get a job offer from about 40% of the interviews I did. Now that I'm pushing 50, it's about 10%. I blame a number of things: * The biggest one is salary. I'm just not willing to work for what I worked for when I was 40. * I haven't kept up with the latest technology as much as I should have. * I'm a bit more risk averse. For instance, when I was 35, I moved to another state for a job. But a lot of it is just plain ageism. I did an interview last Friday, and when I walked in, the company was full of twenty-somethings. I saw the look on the recruiter's face, when he did the math and realized I was way older than he'd assumed. He just looked horrified.
- aswanson 8y agoI've seen it firsthand, and I'm far outside the valley. Experienced, well educated older applicants dismissed by far younger managers giving vague reasoning e.g. "I just didnt see the passion...the energy wasnt there....". Its really sad.
- skybrian 8y agoI don't know about this case, but as you get older and more experienced/cynical, enthusiasm for most of the available programming jobs does become a limited resource, at least for some of us. It's a good idea to try for early retirement if you can.
- xirdstl 8y agoThat's exactly how I feel as well (in my late 30s). After awhile, the passion does wane. Cynically, why would I have passion to work long hours for another startup who is going to "change the world" through marketing ad-tech, possibly failing and leaving me without a paycheck? I've gotten to a position where I'm doing just part-time now, ultimately looking toward early retirement (or, working on whatever I want).
- mockingbirdy 8y agoI'm 20 years old and I feel the same way. Any tips for a young "old soul" software developer that has to work 20 years before he can retire (hopefully)? I've spent half of my life programming and I know that this is my most valuable skill where I can make 10k+/month, but I don't feel any excitement about 90% of the stuff anymore so it's hard to continue. My current plan is to increase my passive income and trading. I love programming, but I'm feeling burned out (I'm doing professional software dev for 3 years now and currently run an agency).
- Spooky23 8y agoEvery time I post a $60k engineer job, I get 30 resumes. There's no shortage.
- locopati 8y agoJust curious, in what part of the world are you hiring and paying engineers only $60k?
- hnbroseph 8y agothere are engineers - in the US - that make half that, or a little more.
- daveFNbuck 8y agoHow many of those are qualified?
- Spooky23 8y agoAbout half.