3 ms·
you are conflating history with sexism/racism, though they overlap. "Computer" was essentially a "technician" who performed calculations, as today you'd have a
by gowld 8y ago
you are conflating history with sexism/racism, though they overlap. "Computer" was essentially a "technician" who performed calculations, as today you'd have a technician to install parts in your machines or do other mechanistic tasks in an operation. It's not so unusual for a word that refers to a human job eventually becomes the name for the machine that replaces that job: dishwasher, messenger, agent. "computer" happens to be the job that is so easy to mechanise cheaply that the human job was made quickly obsolete once the opportunity arose.
The term "Computer" long predated mechanical computers, by centuries.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_computer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_computer
The earliest "computer" jobs tended to exclude women due to sexism.
This photo shows an example of a human computer team that is mostly men (but may have a higher proportion of women than other technical teams in the larger organization)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_computer#/media/File:NASA_human_computers_-_Mary_Jackson_on_far_right_-_Pressure_Tunnel_staff_taken_in_1950s.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_computer#/media/File:NAS...
You're more likely to find women and PoC in "computer roles" than in scientist/engineer roles because they tended to be shut out from higher-level roles they may have been qualified for, leading to an oversupply of their demographic at the lower levels. And those overqualified women/PoC have more notable stories than the non-overqualified women and men in those roles.
- WorldMaker 8y agoAppreciate the extra technical details. The conflation is still a useful shorthand in terms of the discussion of the ad in question: it's wording specifically says "replace engineers" with this mechanical computer. You are right, it doesn't need to state "replace [humans] computers with [mechanical] computers" because that is already implied in the name choice. Whatever the ratio of "over-qualified" human computers were at the time, it was still a non-zero number, and it is useful to remember those "notable stories". Even the "non-over-qualified" members not "notable" enough for memory weren't machines, and you can't claim they had no impact outside of "pure mechanistic tasks"; certainly there was a lot of under-appreciated QA/QC work and inter-personal labor that got shifted around over the years. Any loss of a workforce to automation isn't just "mere" obsoletion, because people aren't machines, and it is good to remember that (conflation, overlaps, or not). Especially for a word like "computer" as opposed to "dishwasher" where we practically never have a reason to "human compute" today, to pull out slide rules and step through some math. (There are still human dishwashers in major restaurants; we still have dishes in our homes that we manually wash in addition to machine washing.)