6 ms·
UK Universities: Is free speech under threat?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- theonewhogroks 8y agoGlad to hear things are not so bad in the UK.
- kadendogthing 8y agoBetteridge's law of headlines.
- tom_ 8y ago"certain" students, "certain" speakers, "certain" discussions - I just can't hear the word "certain" any more without assuming that what I'm reading is yet another angsty, hand-wringing, paranoid-tinged screed about Things These Days, with no specific target, just this anger about these "certain" things that these "certain" people do.
- RobertRoberts 8y agoMaybe here is a more eloquent description of the problem. Also, consider that the writer already feels free speech is so under attack that they are not safe enough to even discuss that free speech is under attack. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LquIQisaZFU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LquIQisaZFU
- kadendogthing 8y agoDo you have another source besides PragerU? They don't exactly have a good record of telling the truth or being impartial on subjects.
- RobertRoberts 8y agoIt's Jordan Peterson talking, he has quite a reputation outside of PragerU. But this one video is very short and sums up the attack on free speech from a unique angle his other videos don't do and it's specifically about universities.
- kadendogthing 8y ago>Jordan Peterson Oh okay.
- kentm 8y agoDangerous people are filling the heads of young people with dangerous nonsense. Who are these people? They are what Jordan Peterson calls “the post-modernists:” neo-Marxist professors who dominate our colleges and universities. And here’s the worst part: we are financing these nihilists with tax dollars, alumni gifts and tuition payments. Time to wise up. Calling Marxists nihilists is contradictory, and Jordon Peterson does not have a good track record of accurately discussing either post-modernism or Marxism. So right off the bat, I don't think this video is going to be a valuable use of my time. Edit: Plus the hyperbolic language included in the description indicates to me that I'm not about to hear an even-handed discussion of the issue that seeks to accurately represent the opinions of the other side.
- RobertRoberts 8y agoHe didn't call "marxists nihilsts" it seems he said "neo-marxists" are, which is fitting in my opinion. The video is short, it's good to hear alternative opinions that challenge your own.
- kentm 8y agoAre neo-marxists not marxists? I talk with actual marxists and not a single one has used this terminology, so this really smells like something made up just so claims like the above can be made. It doesn't seem like a good-faith attempt to understand the positions of the "neo-Marxist professors." In my read of Jordan Peterson's stuff, there's a lot of that going on: claiming misconstrued context or playing semantic games to avoid the heart of the matter that his point of view is just not substantiated. The video is short, it's good to hear alternative opinions that challenge your own. Its good to hear alternative opinions that are well formed, even-keeled, and evidenced. To use an extreme example, I do not need to hear an opinion about how the Earth is flat or maybe white nationalism would be a good thing. Right of the bat, I'm told that these "neo-Marxist" professors are dangerous and encouraged to enter a moral panic about nihilism being taught to kids. That doesn't seem like its going to be a good and informative argument.
- JamesLeonis 8y agoEarlier this year there was the promise of Slavoj Zizek and Jordan Peterson debate this October, but sadly that looks like it isn't going to happen. In the spirit of debate, here are two videos that answer some of Mr. Peterson's points. On Post-Modernism: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cU1LhcEh8Ms https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cU1LhcEh8Ms On Marxism: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uGld3FbDY6s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uGld3FbDY6s
- wemdyjreichert 8y agoExample from the article: the one about Chinese students offended by Chinese state discrimination against Tibetans. The school removed it, even though China really does. Universities are supposed to be a place of shared knowledge and diverse perspectives. Another example Berkeley, a school which, according to USA Today, "has become known more recently for its violent demonstrations between those with opposing viewpoints." Also, the article presented overall statistics, focusing more on university trends than individuals. I think a presentation of how widespread the issue is is more impactful than attacking one particular person/university.
- chipotle_coyote 8y agoExample from the article: the one about Chinese students offended by Chinese state discrimination against Tibetans. The school removed it, even though China really does. The full text of that example from the article is: "At the University of Sheffield, Chinese students complained about a film showing state discrimination against Tibetans in China containing an offensive phrase. It was replaced with a different film, still showing discrimination against Tibetans." It seems to me the last sentence there is rather important for context. Also, the article presented overall statistics, focusing more on university trends than individuals. I think a presentation of how widespread the issue is is more impactful than attacking one particular person/university. Well, yes, and the overall statistics it presented strongly suggest that the answer to the question in the headline -- "Is free speech under threat?" -- is "No, not very much."
- LanceH 8y ago"No, not very much." So, yes?
- WilliamMayor 8y agoIt tickled me that Westminster University has a policy of not allowing people to speak who are intolerant of free speech. Presumably no representative of the university can ever speak. That must be hard for them.
- crooked-v 8y agohttps://extranewsfeed.com/tolerance-is-not-a-moral-precept-1af7007d6376 https://extranewsfeed.com/tolerance-is-not-a-moral-precept-1...
- detcader 8y agoIt is more specifically the case that the idea of free speech as a prized element of a society is under threat, than the actual practice of free speech. We need to be mindful of separate things: actual individual free speech events happening, laws about speech, and society's consideration of free speech as a virtue aren't all the same "free speech" thing. But who is threatening the virtue? Who is The Real Threat To Freedom Here! I think it's actually just various people in various political groups, from progressive students at universities to people with actual power like NY States's Cuomo with his radical anti-BDS laws and executive orders.
- kentm 8y agoI like the distinction here. I find the "no platforming" question the most troublesome, because there should be freedom of association and one should not be forced to provide a venue for views that they disagree with. But at the same time, there is a point where limiting access to a venue has a real detrimental effect on free speech. Universities have an obligation to provide a wide variety of dissenting views and not be eco chambers. But at the same time they have limited space and so they must, at some level, pick and choose which speakers get access to those venues. How does one choose which ideas are valuable enough to get access to limited space?
- detcader 8y agoIt's mind-boggling that it has to be limited. What are universities for? Every day every university should have hundreds of guests thinkers and grad students streaming through doing paid speeches and Q&As. If half of them are Alex Jones fraudsters, ok, let students protest and leaflet outside all they want, which would be even more exchanging of ideas and facts.
- kentm 8y agoIt's mind-boggling that it has to be limited. I meant that in terms of physical space availability, of which there is a finite amount. Theres only so many conference rooms that can house a visiting guest speaker.
- barking 8y agoI find it surprising that the article makes no mention of the suppression of debate on Israel/Palestine in UK universities. https://www.theguardian.com/education/2016/mar/15/academics-take-southampton-university-court-over-israel-conference https://www.theguardian.com/education/2016/mar/15/academics-...
- circlefavshape 8y agoAn odd headline, given that free speech is only a 'negative' right in the UK
- DanBC 8y agoNo it isn't. Read the convention rights.
- dickinson99 8y agoUK doesn't have free speech to begin with.
- favorited 8y ago"Free speech" is a loaded term. In the US, you can't just say whatever you want without consequence, which is what lots of people seem to think "free speech" means. Neither slander nor obscenity are protected by the First Amendment. Same goes for so-called "fighting words." Incitement of lawlessness is not protected. Incitement of suicide will likely be tested soon, but a lower court has ruled it is not protected. And that's just a fraction of the types of speech not protected by the US Constitution.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago"That's a load of old bollocks." In the UK I'm free to say this in public, following a magistrate court's decision in a public obscenity case against the Sex Pistols, caused by their album, "Never mind the bollocks (...)" that the word, bollocks, means "nonsense", not "testicles"; and is, therefore, not an obscenity. And that is how free speech is protected, in the UK, and other modern democracies. _____________ [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Never_Mind_the_Bollocks,_Here%27s_the_Sex_Pistols#Title,_packaging_and_obscenity_case https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Never_Mind_the_Bollocks,_Here%...
- DanBC 8y agoAll the Americans saying this are free to set up an event to support Hizb-ut-Tahir and see how long they last.