3 ms·
My own personal hypothesis on this: it's clear that one skill that used to be important is now much less important, and that's memory. When I was a kid I rememb
by hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
My own personal hypothesis on this: it's clear that one skill that used to be important is now much less important, and that's memory. When I was a kid I remembered dozens of phone numbers, now I know about 3. My fear, though, is that other higher order thinking skills are still very dependent on memory, and as we need to exercise our memory less frequently, other parts of our cognitive abilities suffer.
- SomewhatLikely 8y agoI imagine if you peeked over a teenager's shoulder as they went about their routine phone habits you'd have little idea what was going on through all the memes, inside jokes, cultural references, and slang. I have a hard time believing our ability to memorize is so rigid that it peaked in the period after operators routed calls and before phone books, rolodexes, and contact lists in flip phones. We just put memory to different uses throughout time.
- tralarpa 8y ago> We just put memory to different uses throughout time. I agree. Just look how many site names, youtube channels, game rules, game item stats, memes, pokemon names (is that still a thing?), anime slang, etc. young people can memorize. No /s, I am serious.
- wpietri 8y agoSure, but it's plausible that kind of memory is measured differently. It's been decades since I took an IQ test, but one component was "digit span", where they'd give you longer and longer strings of arbitrary digits and see where you couldn't keep up. As someone programming before copy/paste that was a skill I practiced all the time, so I was freakishly good at it.
- drb91 8y agoThere’s a long tradition of speculating about this going back to Socrates, who famously never wrote because he considered it lazy when memory is the real strength of intellect. I also don’t think that Socrates would have been any stupider had he learned to write, and it’s only through Plato we have a record of him at all.
- User23 8y agoHis argument is that a man who always walks with crutches will have his legs atrophy and that writing is a crutch for memory.
- sixstringtheory 8y agoHe was also worried because written words can’t challenge you. If you read something and _think_ you understand it but actually do not, the book can’t quiz you on it and tell you you’re wrong. He was worried about people gaining false senses of knowledge, and losing the ability to critically analyze and defend ideas.