5 ms·
Nice. A solid demonstration to show next time your webmaster doesn't want to set up SSL everywhere. That said, the current cartel-like setup of certificate au
by Groxx 16y ago
Nice. A solid demonstration to show next time your webmaster doesn't want to set up SSL everywhere.
That said, the current cartel-like setup of certificate authorities (protection money and everything!) makes SSL annoying and expensive if you want the browser to not have a fit. Especially for small-scale projects. But there's really no excuse for larger sites.
- StavrosK 16y agoYou can get SSL certificates for free for one domain, and they work with all browsers (except Opera, IIRC). Also, you can use Perspectives for Firefox, which I think is much better than the current system.
- ryan-allen 16y agoI've had a bit of a look on Google, but I'm not 100% sure which provider you mean? Where can you get free SSL certificates that don't upset browsers?
- StavrosK 16y agoAh, I can't remember the name now... Rapidssl? That's probably it. Check historio.us, the ssl cert there is a free one (which is, sadly, why subdomains don't validate). EDIT: I searched and it's actually http://cert.startcom.org/ http://cert.startcom.org/.
- qeorge 16y agoCheck historio.us, the ssl cert there is a free one (which is, sadly, why subdomains don't validate). AFAIK this is common to all certs (free or otherwise). You need a separate one for each subdomain (including www).
- StavrosK 16y agoNo, there are also wildcard certificates that match all subdomains, but are rather more expensive.
- qeorge 16y agoDidn't know that, thanks.
- carey 16y agoWildcard certificates are available for USD $49.90 from StartSSL (http://www.startssl.com/?app=40 http://www.startssl.com/?app=40), which is rather more expensive than free, but shouldn’t be a hardship.
- irons 16y agoThe only downside to wildcard certs through StartSSL is that getting one requires high-resolution proof of personal identity, to be kept on file outside local jurisdiction (the company's based in Israel) until the cert's final renewal or revocation, plus seven years. I admire their model of only charging for operations which require human intervention, like identity validation, but handing over that degree of documentation for that amount of time requires a lot of trust, not just of the company as it currently exists, but as it will exist in the far future. If there was a way to validate organizations which wasn't layered on top of an earlier validation of an individual, or if their decentralized web-of-trust was usable for class 2/wildcard certs, I'd be a big fan. As it is, there's no reason not to use Start for class 1, single-domain certs, for which the validation is automated and reasonable.
- swolchok 16y agoWildcard certs don't match the underlying domain, though. See, for example, dropbox.com instead of www.dropbox.com; they've got a wildcard cert and it's not valid for dropbox.com.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- sp4rki 16y agoNamecheap provides free ssl certificates for each domain you get through them.
- caf 16y agoRight, and even the paid ones can be had for well under $30/yr nowadays, which is pretty trivial.
- Groxx 16y agoThere are levels of pay for functionality, like subdomains, and being able to issue your own certificates. For instance, from Verisign: a 1 year Microsoft code signing certificate starts at $499 [1]. A top-of-the-line (from their main pages) web certificate for a single server for one year: $1499 [2] [1]: https://securitycenter.verisign.com/celp/enroll/selectOptions?bundle_id=MSIECS002&originator=VeriSign%3ACELP&application_locale=VRSN_US&checkPrice=true&validityPeriod=1&csPro=false&promoCode= https://securitycenter.verisign.com/celp/enroll/selectOption... [2]: https://ssl-certificate-center.verisign.com/process/retail/product_selector;jsessionid=F6D5DFF6EA2FBEA520D0C0BFFBED8EB2?uid=9cb92383b70355b8b51a927172660d91&product=GHA002 https://ssl-certificate-center.verisign.com/process/retail/p... edit: it would figure the links don't work. Just go to www.verisign.com and those are a couple clicks from the front page.
- gasull 16y agoPerspectives doesn't work in the latest version of Firefox. Its home page says a new version is coming, though: http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~perspectives/firefox.html http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~perspectives/firefox.html
- jluxenberg 16y agoOff topic, but re: Perspectives. It allows your browser to compare notes with other nodes on the Internet ('network notaries') to ensure that everyone is seeing the same cert for a given website. Looks like a great idea, but how do they prevent the man-in-the-middle from impersonating a network notary?
- StavrosK 16y agoNotaries sign their responses, if I remember correctly.
- BCM43 16y agoThe monkeysphere is also a good alternative if you use debian and gpg. http://web.monkeysphere.info/ http://web.monkeysphere.info/
- bluesmoon 16y agoSSL is bad for the environment because it requires far more server side hardware... Well, I'm only partially serious about the environment thing, the question is, how can internet companies make it commercially viable to use SSL for everything? The added hardware and power costs make each user way more expensive, possibly to the point where they may not actually be worth it. An alternative is to bind the user's session to their IP address, but that isn't fool proof either because of NAT, DHCP and certain big ISPs that tend to change IPs on the fly. What cost-effective solution would you suggest?
- walkon 16y agoRequire SSL on any request who's response sends a set-cookie http header. Leave it out for the non-sensitive request/responses.
- santry 16y agoYou'd still be able to get the cookie when the client sends it bnack to the server on subsequent, non-SSL requests. It's gotta be SSL all the time.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- EricButler 16y agoWhen Gmail switched on SSL for everyone earlier this year they added "no additional machines" (http://unblog.pidster.com/imperialviolet-overclocking-ssl http://unblog.pidster.com/imperialviolet-overclocking-ssl). Regarding IPs, there's a bigger issue here. People are used to being able to shut their laptop at home and open it back up at work without having to re-authenticate all their browser tabs. If you filter by IP this breaks. SSL requires no changes to user behavior.
- qeorge 16y agoWhat about pairing the auth token with a browser fingerprint? [1] It would make it harder to troll an open network for random victims, and wouldn't annoy the user. [1] Perhaps a hash based on something like this https://panopticlick.eff.org/ https://panopticlick.eff.org/
- jberryman 16y agoStartcom offers free no-BS certificate signing, and their CA is on most modern browsers, I believe. I think they could be suitable for small scale projects.
- limmeau 16y agoHTTPS also needs distinct IP addresses for distinct hostnames, so that the HTTP handshake, in which the Host: header appears, is already protected by an encrypted channel. No more having multiple websites on one IP address.
- loewenskind 16y agoThat's an incredibly drastic change and I seriously doubt it can even be done with IP4.
- pornel 16y agoThere's TLS 1.1 SNI extension which adds vhosts. Works — of course — everywhere except IE6/7XP.