5 ms·
If their sources are from the intelligence community do you really expect them to handover physical chips to the journalists they leak to?
by cm2187 8y ago
If their sources are from the intelligence community do you really expect them to handover physical chips to the journalists they leak to?
- kbenson 8y agoIf the intelligence community expects what they say to be reported as fact, then they need to pony up at least something to verify their claims. Otherwise the news media is just a mouthpiece for the intelligence community. That's particularly bad because one of their jobs is to be a check against just such behavior.
- stevehawk 8y agoBut it likely isn't the IC saying it so much as a whistleblower saying.
- kbenson 8y agoDoes that somehow mean they should be less skeptical and not require more evidence before publishing the whistleblower assertions as fact? Do whistleblowers, by asserting that they are whistleblowers even without evidence, deserve more trust in this scenario for some reason?
- fdsak 8y agoI agree with you, now its normal practice to blame someone without evidence. Intelligence communities around the world are major source of "fake news" and media manipulate. My understanding is that "whistleblowers" are part of experiments done by intelligence communities to gauge public response on certain activities(might be illegal ,immoral) and with passage of time we forget and accept theses practices as new normal.
- stevehawk 8y agoIt doesn't reduce the requirement for evidence, but it's a very realistic "why" when it comes to why they haven't produced any physical evidence.
- ufmace 8y agoOf course intelligence agencies would never do such a thing as have one of their officers pretend to be a whistleblower in order to trick the news media into publishing their propaganda. /s
- acct1771 8y ago> Otherwise the news media is just a mouthpiece for the intelligence community. Ah, the Mockingbird sings...
- dis-sys 8y agoI'd be very careful about the term "the intelligence community", that is the "community" which told the world the WMD story in Iraq.
- tomjakubowski 8y agoThat would be politicians who ignored any of the "IC" analysis that contradicted their claims, and made up their own conclusions from dubious sources of "raw" intelligence like Ahmed Chalabi.
- monocasa 8y agoBullshit. Straight from the CIA's NIE, page 9: > High Confidence: > Iraq is continuing, and in some areas is expanding, its chemical, biological, nuclear and missile programs contrary to UN resolution. > Iraq could make a nuclear weapons in months to a year if it acquired sufficient weapons-grade fissile material. https://www.scribd.com/doc/259216899/Iraq-October-2002-NIE-on-WMDs-unedacted-version https://www.scribd.com/doc/259216899/Iraq-October-2002-NIE-o... I'm not sure where this "the IC is this blameless group that only looks like they screw up because of those pesky politicians" meme came from, but it has no basis in reality.
- fit2rule 8y agoDon't bother trying - its not possible in todays political climate for people to be enlightened as to just how much damage has been done to the world by the 'intelligence' community. The CIA is the #1 source of conflict and trouble in the world - but American citizens have a very hard time with the self-reflection required to see this fact. This is by design: their society has been engineered to allow the secret spooks to rule, comfortably, without interference from public policy makers. Time and again, we see the CIA, and other of US' TLA-agencies, directly causing world turmoil - and yet a blind eye is turned, because "at least its our guys doing it", etc. The world would be a much, much better place if American citizens paid more attention to what their spy masters are doing in the world. Secrecy is the lynchpin of all corruption: the fact that American's worship their secret-keeping institutions as beyond reproach, the reason we have so much turmoil in the world.
- AsyncAwait 8y agoI always wonder why are sources from the intelligence community regarded as distinct? They're fairly integrated, I'd regard them as just one source.