3 ms·
I suppose you are arguing that meritocratic communities aren't the best setup for a community - which is a pretty reasonable one. I mean, the big successful cou
by roenxi 8y ago
I suppose you are arguing that meritocratic communities aren't the best setup for a community - which is a pretty reasonable one. I mean, the big successful countries aren't meritocracies, they are democracies. So fair enough.
> Finally - if you allow abusive people to exist within a community, you by definition exclude everybody who they would abuse.
You are going directly to how a meritocratic society might fail. Meritocratic communities can fail, but so can communities with any ideological underpinning.
Sometimes you have a choice between someone who knows exactly what they are doing but has questionable behaviors vs. someone who doesn't know quite as much but is better behaved. A meritocracy gives power to the first person. We can have long conversations about whether that person should strive to improve themselves over time (pretty easy to answer that question), but change is slow and in the interim a choice has to be made.
- vertex-four 8y agoI’m suggesting that your meritocracy doesn’t exist - if your organisation is structured to exclude people who may (and likely do) have contributions of merit, it is not a meritocracy. Then, the question is simple - who do you exclude? People who abuse others, or the people they abuse? Note that this is a community issue, not a code issue. If somebody wants to sit on their own, publish patches to their own website, and somebody else wants to import those patches into a community project, fine - there’s no non-technical interaction needed there, and little actual reason to exclude their code. It’s excluding them from the community that we’re talking about here.
- roenxi 8y ago> I’m suggesting that your meritocracy doesn’t exist Nothing ideologically pure exists - technically there are no democracies in the world either, because, eg, places like the US dilute the will of the masses with the court system (which is not democratic). It is still a pretty democratic country. > if your organisation is structured to exclude people who may (and likely do) have contributions of merit, it is not a meritocracy Sure it is. That is like saying you can't have a democracy in Australia if people in Tanzania who aren't Australian citizens, because a a palce ruled-by-people is excluding people. It is reasonable to argue that excluding people who have great potential is a bad idea, which it is, but you can still have a meritocracy. > Then the question is simple - who do you exclude? People who abuse others, or the people they abuse? No, that isn't the question at all. The question is simple and it is "how do we support the people making the greatest technical contributions?". In an extreme case, that might mean putting up with some off-color characters who happen to be inspired technical experts. It isn't perfect. What is? But that is what meritocracies do.