5 ms·
Bloomberg claims that there is evidence floating around - unless they're bluffing, they should be able to show evidence of at least one such motherboard, instea
by PeterisP 8y ago
Bloomberg claims that there is evidence floating around - unless they're bluffing, they should be able to show evidence of at least one such motherboard, instead of CGI graphics showing how it might look.
Have they seen any actual hard evidence? Noone is disputing that the described attack vector is possible, but if Bloomberg has not properly verified if it actually has happened, then their article becomes a lie; and if they have properly verified it (as opposed to blindly trusting unnamed sources), why are they seemingly unable to show any hard evidence or details to the public?
- monocasa 8y agoThese were supposedly targeted attacks. Why would Bloomberg have access to AWS and Apple internally designed boards?
- liamkinne 8y ago> internally designed boards What? The allegations are against super micro boards produced in China.
- monocasa 8y agoSuper Micro builds custom designed boards for other businesses given the right quantities. It's a huge part of their business; I wouldn't be surprised if it's bigger than their white box boards. One of the allegations was that special purpose video encoder boards from a hardware startup that Amazon acquired (Elemental) were targeted. These aren't off the shelf boards that anyone can buy.
- PeterisP 8y agoBecause the sources in AWS and Apple who reported this issue to Bloomberg have access to the boards they're reporting about? What details and evidence about these boards have these sources provided to Bloomberg? Are there any details or evidence?
- monocasa 8y agoNot if they've been destroyed or handed over to the authorities.
- chmod775 8y ago"It should be taken as fact because I can't prove it." How about no.
- monocasa 8y agoNo, just that the a absence of evidence isn't the evidence of absence. There's next to no way that Bloomberg's sources would still have access to the boards, and that should be considered given all of the calls here to see them.
- cm2187 8y agoIf their sources are from the intelligence community do you really expect them to handover physical chips to the journalists they leak to?
- kbenson 8y agoIf the intelligence community expects what they say to be reported as fact, then they need to pony up at least something to verify their claims. Otherwise the news media is just a mouthpiece for the intelligence community. That's particularly bad because one of their jobs is to be a check against just such behavior.
- stevehawk 8y agoBut it likely isn't the IC saying it so much as a whistleblower saying.
- kbenson 8y agoDoes that somehow mean they should be less skeptical and not require more evidence before publishing the whistleblower assertions as fact? Do whistleblowers, by asserting that they are whistleblowers even without evidence, deserve more trust in this scenario for some reason?
- fdsak 8y agoI agree with you, now its normal practice to blame someone without evidence. Intelligence communities around the world are major source of "fake news" and media manipulate. My understanding is that "whistleblowers" are part of experiments done by intelligence communities to gauge public response on certain activities(might be illegal ,immoral) and with passage of time we forget and accept theses practices as new normal.
- stevehawk 8y agoIt doesn't reduce the requirement for evidence, but it's a very realistic "why" when it comes to why they haven't produced any physical evidence.