2 ms·
It's not "unrelated", it's an intertwined phenomenon, especially in practical consequences. In Redis, as one primary example I already mentioned, all database p
by WorldMaker 8y ago
It's not "unrelated", it's an intertwined phenomenon, especially in practical consequences. In Redis, as one primary example I already mentioned, all database partitioning is network partitioning (and vice versa). The logical object is still a "database" even if the physical object suffering problems is the "network".
For similar reasons that you suppose they "don't use proper distributed algorithms" (which seems an overly harsh way to put it), I simply presumed the logical entity in question is still a "database", even in the case of a network partition problem. I don't think it was either Postgres or Redis in this case, but they are simple enough examples to illustrate the overall problem.
Either way, my case still seems to stand that we aren't likely to get more information about the specifics of the partition failure because likely both the logical (which "database") and physical layer specifics (which datacenters/"network") are things that are internal to GitHub that they may not be able to publicly describe much more than what they have.
- LaserToy 8y agoIt doesn’t really matter what they used, I just pointed out that their incident report is BS. I can blame virtually any production problem on network, but the ugly truth is - it is not networks fault in most of cases, but fault of engineers who developed the system with unreasonable assumptions.