You need to judge them by the recovery in the context of what happened. GitHub has a world class engineering team, but major outages still happen. Even in the

You need to judge them by the recovery in the context of what happened. GitHub has a world class engineering team, but major outages still happen. Even in the context of a major outage, they have best-in-class status pages and frequent around-the-clock updates. I helped manage a hosted DVCS and CI system in my previous job, and do you know what we would've called an outage that happened at 7:00PM and had recovered partially before start of business? A Tuesday. Wait for the RCA to come out before throwing any stones.