4 ms·
I remember being wowed by this at the time, but, looking back on it now, I think I was maybe just captivated by the fact that they were throwing a bunch of tech
by bunderbunder 8y ago
I remember being wowed by this at the time, but, looking back on it now, I think I was maybe just captivated by the fact that they were throwing a bunch of technology at it, not what it was accomplishing.
I see two ideas for how it might be useful that are practical: Putting windows "out of the way" when they're not being used, and attaching notes to files.
For the first, I'm not sure the 3D works well with how I like to work, because I like to use up all my screen real estate, and a bunch of floating tilted windows are still in the way (because they take up a bunch of space - maybe 15-20% of the real estate of the full window, in the examples from the demo) using this approach. On OS X, by contrast, I have several options, all of which really do get the window completely out of the way - I can hide it, I can minimize it, or I can stick it on its own desktop. Throw a window tiling tool like Spectacle in there, and I get a pretty large amount of power, while still keeping things simple.
Adding notes to files by writing on the back of the window feels odd to me, UX-wise. To view the notes, do I have to open the file and then flip the window around? How do I know that a file has a note, without doing that? I think I'd rather just have a "notes" bit of metadata that is viewable in the file manager.
In general, I think that 3D is maybe just awkward for organization. Evidence: Out in the real world, we have invented all sorts of objects for 2d-izing - or even linearizing - things for organizational purposes. Shelves and file cabinets, for example.
- pmontra 8y agoYes, hiding notes on the back of a window doesn't look a good idea. Furthermore it hides the object of the note from the user when the user is writing the note. One really needs good memory. I looked through the video and I didn't see anything I want to use. Some concepts made their way into some current desktops (the dock, floating windows on alt tab) or maybe were copied from some previous one. I don't use docks, I take my time to remove them from the desktops I use. If I can't, I use a different OS.
- jethro_tell 8y ago3D might have been a solution to limited pixel space. Now, pixels are cheap and abundant, so you can lay everything out and switch back and forth with a flick of your eyes.
- bunderbunder 8y agoI guess. . . but even around that time, when I was doing a lot of work on a pretty pixel-limited laptop screen, I typically made real estate by just having several different virtual terminal sessions (plus one for X). A flick of an F-key to switch VT's wasn't as quick as a flick of the eyes, but it was close enough. And way better than anything that involves reaching for the mouse, which would seem to be an essential part of doing it in a 3D DE.