3 ms·
A long time horizon is supposed to be what governments are good at. No reasonable employee would trust a private insurance company to still be in business by th
by lmm 8y ago
A long time horizon is supposed to be what governments are good at. No reasonable employee would trust a private insurance company to still be in business by the time they come to require, absent a governmental guarantee - and if something is both paid for by the government-as-employer and guaranteed by the government-as-regulator, what is bringing in a private company supposed to add to the mix other than taking profits?
- rrdharan 8y agoSeveral private insurance companies been in business nearly as long as the US government I believe..
- lmm 8y agoWell in reality the insurance industry is highly regulated and ultimately backed by the promise of government bailouts. (Of course some companies from a pre-government-guarantee era are still in business, but "some" isn't enough when we're talking about your retirement savings)
- lotsofpulp 8y agoIt adds transparency and accountability. And it’s up to the government employees if they want to bring in a private company. As a taxpayer, and employer of government employees, I would like a clear accounting of how much payroll is. I don’t want politicians buying union votes with unsustainable promises that get kicked down the road 20 years later, and I don’t want to hear “my predecessors didn’t properly fund the pensions”. You create a system loopholes and bad incentives, of course they are going to be used. The solution is simple, time saving, and efficient. If a private entity can’t afford to offer annuities without the power to increase taxes, then they are obviously a very, very expensive benefit, so why should only government employees get them?
- lmm 8y ago> If a private entity can’t afford to offer annuities without the power to increase taxes, then they are obviously a very, very expensive benefit, so why should only government employees get them? Because the government can provide them more cheaply than a private entity by its very nature - shouldn't it make use of that competitive advantage? Better pension schemes are one of the ways government are able to offer a competitive employee compensation package despite substantially below-market headline salaries; if you replaced the guaranteed annuities with their market dollar value that would mean costing the government more to be able to hire the same people, offering government employees less value overall and so getting lower-quality employees, or both.
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>Because the government can provide them more cheaply than a private entity by its very nature Please justify this. Public sector is not known for it's low overhead of efficiency.
- lmm 8y ago> Please justify this. The point is the government is already "too important to fail" and already bearing the costs of having to still exist in hundreds of years' time (in terms of plans, processes, backstops and all that). > Public sector is not known for it's low overhead of efficiency. True enough, but neither are large private financial institutions.
- pc86 8y agoNone of what you've said explains how a government can offer an annuity more cheaply than a private company.
- lmm 8y agoFor a private company to offer an annuity that an employee can have the same level of confidence in, the private company would have to do those too-important-to-fail things, and would have to include the costs of them in the cost of the annuity, which the government does not.