3 ms·
> There’s no reason government employees should get taxpayer guaranteed annuities There is. In Germany, the Prussians back in the 18th century formed the "Beru
by mschuster91 8y ago
> There’s no reason government employees should get taxpayer guaranteed annuities
There is. In Germany, the Prussians back in the 18th century formed the "Berufsbeamtentum", basically civil servants. The idea is that the state guarantees that the Beamten be permanently employed by the state (basically, short of committing serious crimes > 12mo jail time, there is no way for the state to fire one), have their (first class) healthcare taken care of and that they will have decent pensions. For this, the Beamten bind their work life to the state.
The downside, of course, is that there are several limits for Beamte: most notably they must be absolutely loyal to the state, restrict themselves/their speech in the public (e.g. memberships in "extremist" parties are a no-go), they are forbidden from strikes, and their pay schedules are fixed (so, no individual contract agreements, everyone on the same step of the career ladder gets the same salary). Also (mostly valid for police officers and judges) the state may decide to reassign you to a different post... which may even be at the other end of the country, for those who are with the federal government.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoI don’t see what the benefit of that system is as opposed to paying someone market price for their labor. If anything, it just allows an avenue for taxpayers (mostly in the future) to be stolen from.
- mschuster91 8y ago> I don’t see what the benefit of that system is as opposed to paying someone market price for their labor. The benefit is that Beamte are locked in to the state. It's rare that the private sector snatches Beamte away from the state. This means that, unlike in the private sector, the state does not have to worry that its most competent employees suddenly vanish.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoThe same can be accomplished by paying them market wages. In addition, it would provide a transparent accounting of expenditures and prevent politicians and union leaders and others from scamming taxpayers like they currently are.
- mschuster91 8y ago> The same can be accomplished by paying them market wages. No. Even with paying market wages, there can someone come along and flood the market with cheap money. Then the state has to massively counteract and waste taxpayer money. Beamtentum is the core of German societal stability, as a result.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoI don't know what "flooding with cheap money" means, but by definition, if a buyer is outbid by another buyer for something, then the market price has changed so the previous buyer needs to update to the new market price. I don't understand how this is a waste of taxpayer money, since it properly indicates to people where resources need to be shifted (in order to bring prices down). Without this market mechanism, you actually have a waste of taxpayer money since you don't know what you're overpaying/underpaying for. The societal stability part should be offered to all taxpayers, not just government employees, so I don't see why that would be tied to an employer at all.
- mschuster91 8y ago> I don't know what "flooding with cheap money" means, but by definition, if a buyer is outbid by another buyer for something, then the market price has changed so the previous buyer needs to update to the new market price. Foreign money comes into a city and artificially (= not backed by local growth) drives up the prices, gobbles up the knowledge, then leaves. The city however is stuck with their now inadequately overpaid employees, which of course have every incentive to leave once the city inevitably tries to lower their pay again, thus basically holding the city at gunpoint: pay us or you shut down. Just imagine how the finances of the Silicon Valley cities would be in that scenario - if they would go with the exorbitant pay rates for IT employees also for city staff, and another dotcom bust/financial crisis hits. The startups fold up, and the government is locked into now-enormous wages for the city employees. And please don't act as if this wouldn't happen - half of SV economy / wealth is built up on dirt cheap Saudi blood money (as e.g. Uber and many others are finding out in the wake of the Khashoggi murder), and in Europe it's Chinese and Russian money instead of Saudi money. It's not a question of IF a bust happens, just WHEN. London is about to blow up in Brexit, I'm waiting for the chain reactions. I'm not a fan of many German eccentric policies, but the Beamtentum is something that will keep the government running no matter how colossal the fuck-up. For example, something like the US gov't shutdowns is unimaginable here.