2 ms·
I specifically said that these cases were not comparable because they are covered by different civil rights laws. My objection is to your use of "I don't think
by eesmith 8y ago
I specifically said that these cases were not comparable because they are covered by different civil rights laws.
My objection is to your use of "I don't think income is a protected class, therefore the government shouldn't care". "Protected class" has a wider meaning in civil rights law.
I pointed to other cases where seemingly generic prohibitions, which are not themselves protected classes, have a sufficiently high correlation with a prohibited class that the courts have ruled that the generic prohibition (no shaving, height requirement, clothing styles, and more) is a violation of civil rights law.
Some of these are almost certainly portable to enrollment policies. A college which receives federal funding won't be able to use a genetic test to prohibit those carrying the sickle cell anemia mutation, because of its strong correlation with race.
So while I think there are certainly valid objections to jakelazaroff's original statement "Preference for children of donors and legacies are such blatantly racist admission policies", and I agree that income is not and should not be a protected class, and I agree that there can be bona fide business reasons to have a preference for wealthy people, the case law is pretty solid that discrimination on X where X is not a protected class can still result in the government caring.
- lalos 8y agoWe're on the same page then. Thanks for your explanation, I misunderstood your other comments.